September 2026 FOMC: “The Trend is the Trend”

The outcome of the September FOMC meeting was far from predetermined, not in terms of the policy action, but in terms of the signals the Committee would send. Overall, we think the Fed took an important step in the right direction, and Kevin Warsh handled a very difficult press conference effectively. Most importantly, the Committee finally appears determined to disinflate the U.S. economy.

Among the scenarios we circulated ahead of the meeting, the outcome appears closest to our strong growth scenario, with the federal funds rate path broadly consistent with that simulation – see below for details. The main tension between the SEP and our models remains the amount of tightening required to bring inflation back to target within a reasonably short period. While the Fed now signals a terminal rate of 4.1%, our models suggest that a rate closer to 5.5% would be required. We do not know whether the Fed will ultimately go that far, but today marks a shift toward a more restrictive path, potentially involving quarterly hikes until inflation provides convincing evidence of improvement.

The main question mark concerns the 3.4% core PCE projection for 2026. This appears difficult to reconcile with Warsh’s statement that core PCE should be around 3.2% in August, which implicitly suggests, in line with our estimates, that the forthcoming BEA revisions will lower year over year core PCE by around two tenths. Starting from 3.2% in August, a 3.4% Q4 over Q4 forecast looks relatively high and may partly reflect the need to justify the two hikes embedded in the 2026 policy path rather than a genuine forecast.

The broader message is that the FOMC finally appears determined to address persistent inflation. The focus has clearly shifted toward the underlying trend and our estimates continue to place trend inflation between 2.5% and 3%, well above target (our estimate of trend inflation is here). The inflation saga therefore remains very much alive. The really good news is that we thought Warsh today delivered a very strong performance.

Statement

The statement is slightly more hawkish than the previous one, although overall our reading is simply that the Committee has acknowledged that the economy remains solid and that it can therefore proceed with the rate hike.

The dots

The new SEP projections are finally much more realistic than those published in June, and even more so than those released in March. In terms of revisions, perhaps the only genuine surprise from our perspective is the 3.4% projection for core PCE inflation in 2026. This appears to be a forecast that does not incorporate the potential impact of the BEA methodological revisions due later this month.* Alternatively, it may simply reflect a deliberate choice by the Committee to preserve enough room to justify two rate hikes in 2026.

Among the scenarios we circulated ahead of the meeting, our “strong growth scenario”  overlaps almost perfectly with the new SEP projections (our note is here). We reproduce it below for reference. This therefore appears to be broadly the macroeconomic scenario currently envisaged by the Committee. The difference now between the FOMC and the model is that according to the latter the terminal rate required to bring inflation back to target remains substantially above the 4.1% peak indicated in the SEP.

* The staff’s estimate of the expected revision appears to be around two tenths. This can be inferred from the Chair’s opening remarks during the press conference, where he indicated that core PCE inflation should stand at around 3.2% in August, whereas our pre revision translation implies 3.4%. This implicitly suggests that the staff expects the BEA revisions to lower year over year core PCE inflation by around two tenths, which is exactly in line with our own estimate. At the same time, this reinforces our view that the 3.4% core PCE projection for 2026 reported in the SEP is probably too high.

Figure 1. Comparison between FRB-US latest forecasts (red lines) and the September SEP (blue lines and areas).

Figure 2. Comparison between FRB-US latest forecasts (red lines) and FRB-US “strong growth” scenario (gray lines).

Q&As

Question: You said “timely return to target” but in the SEP core PCE goes back to 2% only in 2029. How do you square those two things?

Warsh. “One easy way to square that, Mike, is those aren’t my forecasts. Those are the forecasts of my eighteen colleagues, and I’ve tried to represent them dutifully to you. My business is to not give forward guidance, but my commitment in June was to reaffirm to the American people, to anyone listening, that we will deliver price stability. My commitment in July was to say we want to buy a little bit of time. We want to evaluate what’s happening across a range of dimensions. And what I said in Jackson Hole in August is we’re committed to a discipline, not to a decision. Today’s action starts to show we’re serious about this, and we will deliver on the price stability objective. And as the statement said, we’ll do it on a timelier basis. That’s our decision, and when we continue our discussions over the course of the next several weeks and months, we’ll have more to say about it. But I’m ill prepared to prejudge those future actions..”

Comment: This is exactly the tension that has existed for some time between the SEP and the models. Today, the Fed took a significant step by indicating that the terminal rate should reach 4.1%, but the models continue to imply a substantially higher terminal rate if the objective is to bring inflation back to target within a reasonably short period of time. We do not know whether the Fed will ultimately be willing to go as far as 5.5%. For now, it has settled on 4.1%. However, the question put to the Chair on this issue was entirely appropriate, and his answer was somewhat evasive.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.