US: FRB-US – Hike or Not?

In this note, we present four scenarios simulated using FRB US to assess whether the Federal Reserve is likely to raise interest rates. Ultimately, however, we conclude that the model provides relatively limited guidance in this case, as it does not generate a sufficiently clear policy signal. We therefore believe that this week’ s CPI report and, crucially, the details of the CPI to PCE translation will ultimately determine the Fed’s decision.

Just a reminder that, in each panel of the figures below, the current baseline is shown by the red lines, while the alternative scenario is shown by the grey lines. We also remind readers that these scenarios can be replicated directly on our website using the Build Your Scenario tool we have developed.

Scenario #1 Core PCE revised lower

We simulate a path broadly consistent with what we currently expect the revised core PCE series to look like. Once again, the model does not imply a rate hike. In fact, it suggests that the federal funds rate should remain broadly unchanged throughout 2026, before rate cuts begin in 2027. This outcome is fully consistent with the Taylor rule embedded in the model.

We remind readers that this is not a remote scenario. At present, it is broadly consistent with what our translation and our estimates of the forthcoming BEA revisions suggest the new core PCE path could look like.

Scenario #2. Stronger real GDP growth

In the second scenario, we assume a positive demand shock in the third quarter. Specifically, we assume that real GDP growth is one percentage point higher, on a quarter over quarter seasonally adjusted annualized basis, than in our baseline, where we currently assume growth of 2.7%.

By construction, this produces a stronger growth scenario, and under these assumptions the model does indeed imply a Fed rate hike. There is still considerable uncertainty about the Q3 GDP outcome, although some nowcasts currently suggest that growth could turn out to be stronger than assumed in our baseline.

Scenario #3. Committed Fed

The third scenario addresses a question we continue to receive frequently, namely whether a single Fed rate hike would actually make a meaningful difference. The model continues to suggest that, if the objective were to ensure disinflation and bring inflation back to 2% with a high degree of confidence, the federal funds rate would need to rise to around 5%, or even 5.5%, in the current environment.

We do not know, of course, whether such a scenario is realistic. However, under current conditions, one or two rate hikes would probably operate primarily as a signal of the Fed’s commitment to price stability, while providing no guarantee that inflation would return to target.

Scenario #4. Higher R*

The fourth scenario assumes a higher level of R star, which we increase from 1.1% to 1.5%. We frequently receive this comment from clients, as many of you appear to believe that R star is currently closer to 1.5%.

By construction, a higher R star implies a more hawkish path for the federal funds rate and the model still fails to bring core inflation back to target.

Conclusion

The conclusion remains the same as the one outlined at the beginning of this note. For this FOMC meeting, it is particularly difficult at this stage to determine from FRB US whether the Fed will raise rates. Although we do not believe this is necessarily the most appropriate way to conduct monetary policy, the decision appears likely to be determined largely by the outcome of the August CPI and PPI reports.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.