October 2025 FOMC: The (FRB) Doubt

The Doubt.

The outcomes of the October FOMC meeting were somewhat less dovish than anticipated, and notably more aligned with the signals from the models. Let us take a step back. In our September note (here), we wrote: “The FOMC is managing the labor market risk. But according to the models, it is also taking a risk with inflation. Time will tell.” Since then, the FRB-US model has adopted a more hawkish stance (latest analysis here) and suggests no additional rate cuts this year mainly because the labor market is expected to move sideways. Today, the model and the FOMC have come a bit closer to each other.

Indeed, from our perspective, Chair Powell conveyed two key messages:

  1. There are emerging doubts within the FOMC. Some members appear to be reconsidering the degree of labor market weakness. It is possible the labor market is not as soft as previously assumed, and that the FRB-US model may once again prove accurate.

  2. Moderately above-target inflation may be tolerated. In the Q&A session, Powell indicated that if inflation remains moderately above the 2% target, the Committee may be willing to accept that outcome.

All in all, Powell was slightly less dovish than we had anticipated, partially because of the lack of data. In any case, we view this shift as justified and driven by good news: the Fed is gradually acknowledging that the models may have a point and the economy might be more resilient than anticipated.

Statement

The new statement, as expected. We see nothing relevant in the new statement.

Q&As

This time there was only one relevant question about inflation.

Question: What is your view of the last CPI report?

Powell. “[…] directionally, you know, it was a little softer than expected, and we always break it down into the three components. So basically, you’ve seen goods prices increasing, and that’s really due to tariffs. And that’s compared to a longer run trend of very, very mild deflation in goods. So that’s moving inflation up. […] Housing services inflation has been coming down. So, if you remember a couple of years ago, that’s the one that we kept expecting it to do that. Now it’s doing, it’s been doing that for some time. […] That leaves the biggest category: services other than housing services. And that’s kind of been moving sideways over the last few months. But a significant part of that is non-market services. So, we don’t take a lot of signal about the economy from that. If you add all that up, a couple things to say. One is that inflation away from tariffs is actually not so far from our 2% goal. We estimate that […] core PCE not including tariff might be 2.3 or 2.4 in that range, something like that. And the thing about tariff inflation is that it will come, and it probably will increase further but it will be a one-time increase.”

Comment: Ok, now it’s down to non-market prices.. and this comes after 58 months of inflation above target. Quite creative! On the other hand, we find more interesting the second part of Powell’s words. To us, this suggests that the FOMC can (and will) tolerate inflation moderately above target going forward if necessary.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.