ECI Says “We Were Right”

“There is no Phillips Curve”, They Say

A victory lap for UnderlyingInflation research. Against consensus, we argued that wages were not really slowing (see here and here). It was a tough call, given than nearly everyone was on the other side. But we work with no institutional constraints or pressures to sell a view. Our approach is simple: we present the evidence of our models and we try to explain when/where they might be right or wrong. This time, it paid off: ECI has spoken. 

In this note, we update our ECI model and discuss the evidence from an heterodox ECI Phillips curve.

The incoming data

According to the BLS, over the three months ending in March, total compensation for private industry workers increased 4.7% QoQ (a.r.) and 4.8 percent YoY. Wages and salaries increased 5.0 percent for the 12-month period ending in March 2023 and increased 4.7 percent for the 12-month period ending in March 2022. Benefit costs increased 4.5 percent over the year and increased 4.1 percent for the 12month period ending in March 2022.

Our model-based forecast

The inclusion of the first quarter in the sample resulted in a marginal upward revision of the model forecast (1 tenth higher at the end of the medium-term) as the incoming data were a bit stronger than the model expected. The YoY of ECI total compensation for private industry workers is now projected at 4.3 percent in 2023, 3.4 percent in 2024, and 2.9 percent in 2025 (see Figure 1). 

(For the record: we have run the model using other measures of “slack” and we got similar results. Please, remember that following the Fed staff we have now folded in a (mild) recession in our assumptions, therefore the deceleration in the model forecast reflects some of the assumptions we have made)

Figure 1. Phillips curve model-based ECI forecast

Current forecast, model-based

Comparison: current vs. previous forecast (QoQ and YoY)

Note: the figure shows the ECI Phillips curve model-based forecast (YoY). The chart refers to the year-over-year percent changes of compensation costs for private industry workers. The confidence intervals are based on the estimated parameters distributions. The table on the right shows a comparison between the current forecast (2023:Q1 last quarter in-sample) and the previous forecast (stopping the sample in 2022:Q4).

An heterodox Phillips curve

An heterodox Phillips curve suggests there is no free lunch: wage growth disinflates when labor market cools off. Figure 2 shows what can be labeled as “an heterodox Phillips curve”. The figure shows the traditional relation between ECI total compensation growth (3m changes ar) and a measure of slack. Each point is a month calculated by linearly interpolating the quarterly level of the ECI. As a measure of “slack” we plot the difference between the unemployment rate and the jobs opening rate. The idea is that we remain agnostic about the current slope of the Beveridge curve, although we continue to think that the assumptions behind Figura and Waller (2022) were too optimistic (see here our August 2022 note on the point). While it is unclear what side of the Beveridge curve will dominate going forward, a convincing disinflation that brings ECI growth to about 3% requires our measure of “slack” to be around 0%. Put it simply: until the vacancy rate will fall another 2.5pp or the unemployment rate will rise significantly (or a combination of the two), we will remain skeptical that wage growth can moderate to a level consistent with the Fed target.

The evidence is clear: there is clearly a strong link between labor market “slack” and wage growth. “There is no Phillips curve”, they say; but it is wrong. We cannot have everything: super high vacancy rate, ultra low unemployment rate and 3% wage growth. Something has to give or the Fed will miss its 2% target.

Figure 2. An heterodox ECI Phillips curve (2010-2023 monthly data)

Conclusion

A cold shower for the Fed staff and the FOMC. Net of noise, in the last year or so, we have made little progress. How can the Fed start cutting rates with nominal wage growth around 5% and going sideways? Once again, time for the Fed staff and the FOMC to accept reality.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.