The Atlanta Fed Wage Tracker released today confirms our analysis on the Average Hourly Earnings: there is little evidence that nominal wages are slowing. We show why, in our estimates, today’s release implies that the wages and salaries portion of the Employment Cost Index (ECI) might increase 4.4% (QoQ, ar) in the first quarter of this year, implying that the YoY would remain close to 5%. As for the ECI as a whole (that is, including benefits) we expect a 4.0% (QoQ, ar) reading with the YoY moving down to 4.6% due to base effects. Overall, the continuing strength of nominal wages does complicate the Fed job. The economy is slowing, but some portions of consumers prices might remain solid, unless the labor market cools off substantially.
The facts
Nominal wage growth is going sideways. Figure 1 shows the Atlanta Fed Wage Tracker, both the smooth and the unsmoothed index. As a reminder, the tracker calculates the median of individual wage growth using Current Population Survey (CPS) data, excluding individuals with an annual income above 150,000 US$. Therefore, the tracker does not suffer from aggregation biases as the Average Hourly Earnings and tends to reflect more the wage growth of the lower part of the (overall) income distribution. The evidence of Figure 1 is clear: nominal wage growth -at 6½ percent- has been going sideways for more than 1 year with no evidence of a slowdown.
(Note: the tracker is published only as YoY, therefore we do not have the growth rate at the margin. However, we have calculated the 3m/3m and 6m/6m under reasonable assumptions and unsurprisingly they both suggest that at the margin wages are growing at the same rate of the YoY. It is unsurprisingly because the YoY itself has been going sideways for more than a year now, implying neither acceleration nor deceleration).
Figure 1. Atlanta Fed Wage Tracker (YoY)
Implications for the ECI
A model suggests ECI growth might go sideways in Q1. Figure 2 shows the correlation between the ECI wage and salaries (private industry, all workers, YoY) and the Atlanta Fed wage tracker (minus 0.7% to account for the typical gap between the two series). The evidence is clear: there is a very high correlation between the two, even higher than between the ECI wages and salaries and the Average Hourly Earnings (0.90 correlation coefficient vs 0.78).
We have set up a model to forecast the Employment Cost Index (details available upon request), based on the AHE, the tracker and some measures of slack. According to the model, the QoQ (ar) of ECI wages and salaries is expected at 4.4% (ar) in Q1, implying the YoY at 4.9%. As for the ECI as a whole (that is, including benefits), the model expects Q1 (QoQ) growth at 4.0% (ar), which implies the YoY at 4.6%.
Figure 2. Atlanta Fed Wage Tracker (YoY) and the Employment Cost Index Wages and Salaries (YoY)
Conclusion and implications for the Fed
Can service inflation slowdown? Putting everything together, and looking at all measures of wages and salaries, it is fair to conclude that nominal wage and total compensation are growing at around 4½% (ar), with little deceleration. The current wage growth remains around 1½pp above the level consistent with the Fed target. Until the labor market cools off substantially, we remain skeptical that some portions of the consumers’ basket (especially core services ex rents/OER) can run at the desired level by the Fed.