A brief update ahead of the November CPI release. Late last night, in an unexpected move, the BLS published a note providing additional guidance on the effects of the government shutdown on the CPI. Notably, it announced that for some items the November CPI will rely on an imputation technique that is rarely used, known as the carry-forward methodology.
Mechanically, this raises the possibility—already highlighted by other commentators—that the BLS may be introducing a downward bias into the CPI. Quantifying this bias is, of course, difficult. Based on our preliminary calculations this morning, however, it could plausibly amount to around 10 basis points relative to our forecast. Recall that our core CPI forecast was 23 basis points, already at the low end of the consensus distribution, precisely because we anticipated the possibility of imputations by the BLS. (please also keep in mind that comparing MoM forecasts across forecasters this month is almost impossible, as everyone has different assumptions about October levels).
In light of this new information, we now see the year-on-year core CPI not at 3.0 percent, as in our preview, but to 2.9 percent. That said, we urge a high degree of caution. Significant uncertainty remains, and this report is particularly prone to surprises in either direction. Whatever number the BLS releases today, we would expect some degree of offset or “payback” in subsequent months. If today’s reading turns out to be very low, we would anticipate a reversal as the level of the series adjusts in the months ahead. For certain components—most notably rents and OER—this bias may persist for several months, potentially up to six.
Finally, a brief technical note. We have adjusted our programs and code accordingly. Even so, given the circumstances, we cannot be certain about the exact timing of the release of our CPI report today. The CPI-to-PCE translation also remains a significant question mark and is likely less reliable than usual for those of you using the Excel files. Should anyone need quicker feedback, as always, please feel free to reach out by email or to jump on a call.
Good luck, everyone!