US: FRB-US Scenarios – An Update

Preamble. The new baseline is here. The shochastic simulations around the baseline are here and a set of impulse response functions (IRFs) generated using PING program are here.

Please note that in the model, IRFs are symmetric—meaning the figures presented can be “flipped” to reflect a shock of the opposite sign.

In the charts below, the red dashed line represents the current model baseline, while the gray solid line depicts the constructed scenario. We display results only for the federal funds (FF) rate and real GDP growth. However, a full set of results is available for each scenario—feel free to reach out if interested.

Scenario#1: Recession scenario

In this simulation, we introduced an exogenous shock (applied through add factors distributed across demand components) that leads to a recession. Compared to previous simulations, the magnitude of the add factors required to trigger a recession is now smaller, as the baseline is weaker than in earlier runs. For instance, Q1 real GDP growth is projected at -1.6% QoQ SAAR, a milder contraction than some nowcasts suggest.

The GDP contraction (YoY) reaches nearly 1% by Q4 2025. In this scenario, the federal funds rate declines significantly in 2025 and 2026, the unemployment rate rises to 6%, and core inflation returns to target.

Note: the red dashed line shows the current  model baseline, while the solid gray line shows the constructed scenario. Real GDP is expressed as YoY.

Scenario #2. Term premium shocks

In this scenario, we simulate a negative one-time 100bps shock to the 10-year premium, 75bps to the 5-year premium and 35bps to the 30-year premium. As a result, real GDP growth improves in both 2025 and 2026. The unemployment rate peaks between 4.3% and 4.4%, while core inflation remains above target through 2027. Consequently, the federal funds rate stays above the baseline, hovering around 4% in the medium term.

Note: the red dashed line shows the current  model baseline, while the solid gray line shows the constructed scenario. Real GDP is expressed as YoY.

Scenario #3: Equity premium shock

In this scenario, we simulate a one-time 100 bps increase in the equity premium, leading to a 24% drop in stock market wealth before gradually returning to the baseline by Q4 2027.

As a result, growth falls below the baseline, but the overall impact remains limited. This is primarily because the marginal propensity to consume out of wealth stock is very low in the model.

Note: the red dashed line shows the current  model baseline, while the solid gray line shows the constructed scenario. Real GDP is expressed as YoY.

Scenario #4: Weaker than expected foreign growth

In this scenario, we assume weaker foreign growth, leading to a gradual decline in export levels, which are 13 percentage points below the baseline by Q4 2027.

As a result, GDP growth slows and only begins to recover toward the end of the medium term. The federal funds rate follows a more dovish path compared to the baseline.

Note: the red dashed line shows the current  model baseline, while the solid gray line shows the constructed scenario. Real GDP is expressed as YoY.

Scenario #5. Appreciation of the dollar

In this scenario, we simulate a one-time appreciation of the broad dollar, reaching 10% above the baseline by Q4 2027.

As a result, GDP growth declines, and inflation faces downward pressure. The unemployment rate peaks at 4.8%, while the federal funds rate ends the medium term slightly below the baseline.

Note: the red dashed line shows the current  model baseline, while the solid gray line shows the constructed scenario. Real GDP is expressed as YoY.

Scenario #6: Higher R*

In this scenario, we raise R* to 1.5%. As a reminder, the model requires an exogenous assumption for R*, which we typically align with the SEP.

A higher R* mechanically leads to a higher federal funds rate by the end of the medium term. While the impact on growth is noticeable, it remains limited, and the unemployment rate moves sideways.

Note: the red dashed line shows the current  model baseline, while the solid gray line shows the constructed scenario. Real GDP is expressed as YoY.

Scenario #7: DOGE

In this scenario, we simulate one-time permanent DOGE cuts to federal spending. The idea is to assess the level of cuts that can lower growth or trigger a recession. The figure shows 3 scenarios (gray line, green line, and purple line) corresponding to 150bn cuts (about 0.6% of GDP), 300bn cuts (about 1.2% of GDP), and 450bn cuts (a little less than 2% of GDP), respectively. In each case, we assume that two-thirds of the cuts impact discretionary spending, while one-third affects labor costs. 

While significant uncertainty remains regarding the actual extent of DOGE cuts, our findings suggest that a much larger reduction than currently expected would be required to meaningfully slow growth.

Note: the red dashed line shows the current  model baseline, while the solid gray line shows the constructed scenario. Real GDP is expressed as YoY.

Scenario #8: Uncertainty Shock

In this scenario, we simulated an uncertainty shock (for the record, some uncertainty indexes have reached all time highs in the last few weeks). The shock is simulated through a combination of lower private consumption and investment, lower foreign growth, higher inflation expectations, and an equity premium shock (Since FRB-US does not directly model uncertainty shocks, these effects had to be carefully calibrated).

The results are clear: uncertainty poses a significant risk, as it can substantially reduce growth.

Note: the red dashed line shows the current  model baseline, while the solid gray line shows the constructed scenario. Real GDP is expressed as YoY.

Conclusion. As we previously noted, “The Times They Are a-Changin’.” The message is clear: the baseline is somewhat weaker than in previous runs.

When factoring in some of the shocks outlined above, growth falls well below potential, ranging between 0% and 1%. If all shocks were to materialize, a recession can no longer be ruled out—though, as discussed, the probability of such an event remains relatively low.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.