US: July CPI Q&As and Strong PCE

Given the importance of this week’s CPI release, and the number of questions we have received in recent days, we are circulating a very short note with a few Q&As that we hope will serve as a useful pre-flight checklist ahead of this week’s report.

How confident are you in your 0.3 MoM core CPI forecast? More in general, is this a high-conviction month for your CPI forecast?

This month, our core CPI forecast rounds to 0.3%, but the underlying estimate is 26 basis points, meaning that it is only marginally above the rounded consensus forecast. We therefore do not see anything close to the discrepancy we observed in previous rounds, particularly last month. Moreover, our ML model is actually pointing to downside risks around consensus, leaving us with somewhat conflicting signals across the two frameworks.

For this reason, our call this month is not particularly high conviction, for the reasons discussed in our white paper. A call becomes high conviction primarily when both models, our bottom-up framework and the ML model, point in the same direction. In this case, the two models are sending different signals for core inflation. For headline CPI, our bottom-up forecast is broadly in line with consensus, while the ML model is below consensus and therefore points to downside rather than upside risks.

The last two month have been particularly strong for our forecasts. Two months ago, our point forecast was very accurate, while last month we correctly anticipated the direction of the surprise. This month, however, we do not have the same clear and unambiguous signal across the models.

Are PCE prices likely going to be solid/strong?

Yes, this is a possibility. The reason is that non-market prices are likely to be relatively strong once again, largely because one component, portfolio management fees, is expected to post a particularly large increase this month. Below we report the forecast from our model, which is also available on our website and currently points to a MoM increase of 5.17%. In our CPI-to-PCE translation, we have incorporated a somewhat smaller increase, although the final outcome remains to be seen. (Note: technically, this happens because July is the first month after the end of a calendar quarter, and some respondents report only on a quarterly basis).

Even under this more conservative assumption, this component alone is likely to make a meaningful contribution to core PCE inflation, which we currently expect to increase by around 27 basis points in July. This estimate has been revised slightly since our CPI preview.

Figure. Our Portfolio Fees model forecast.

Note: available at underlyinginflation.com

Would a 0.3 core PCE change the outlook for the Fed?

We believe that, regardless of the exact core CPI and PCE prints, Warsh is likely to adopt a more hawkish tone at Jackson Hole this year, at least partly correcting the communication errors made at the latest FOMC meeting. Should core PCE actually print at 0.3% MoM, we would expect markets to increase the probability assigned to a Fed rate hike, potentially taking it above 60%.

That said, we are still relatively far from the September FOMC meeting, and a substantial amount of information remains to be incorporated into the Fed’s reaction function, including another labor market report, complementary labor market indicators, soft data, another CPI reading, and the BEA revisions. The latter will not formally enter the September SEP data cutoff, but the information contained in the revisions will probably already influence policymakers’  projections.

Our baseline would nevertheless remain for no rate hike in September. At the latest SEP, the FOMC projected core PCE inflation at 3.3% for 2026 while signaling no rate hike, whereas our current forecast stands at 3.1%. Therefore, even in the event of a modest upside surprise in the incoming inflation data, core PCE would likely remain below the approximately 3.5% threshold that we estimate would be required for the Fed to respond by raising rates. On the information currently available, we would therefore continue to expect the FOMC to remain on hold in September.

How confident are you about your pre-CPI/PPI to PCE translation?

As always, we try to make our translation as accurate as possible, but there is an important limitation to the exercise. Our translation is based on 22 CPI items, corresponding to the components for which we produce bottom-up forecasts (plus 3 PCE-specific items: PCE medical, PCE airfares, and PCE non-market prices). In principle, forecasting every individual CPI component would allow us to construct a more granular translation, but it would also expose the CPI forecast itself to substantially greater forecasting error.

For this reason, every CPI or PPI release inevitably contains some information that surprises us, or at least generates a revision relative to our prior assumptions. Producing an accurate CPI and PPI to PCE translation before the CPI report is available is extremely difficult and, in practice, close to impossible.

We therefore report the estimate generated by our framework and attempt to make it as accurate as possible given the information available at the time. However, the ex-post translation can change quite materially once the underlying CPI and PPI details become available. This is not a limitation specific to our methodology, but rather an inherent constraint faced by essentially anyone attempting this exercise, since producing reliable forecasts for every individual CPI component is practically impossible.

Can PCE prices be higher than you expect?

Absolutely. In this respect, this month may well be one of those cases in which PCE ultimately comes in stronger than we currently expect. More generally, PCE readings have tended to be stronger than their CPI counterparts in recent months, so we would not be particularly surprised to see the same pattern again this month. As usual, however, we will reassess the translation once the CPI report is available.

More broadly, we have already started to incorporate a somewhat stronger ex ante PCE translation than we would normally have used, precisely to account for the pattern observed over the past few months.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.