What clients are asking
Several of you have inquired: “What kind of conditions would trigger a 50, 75, or even 100 basis point rate cut in 2025, according to the FRB-US model?” To address this, we conducted a series of simulations.
The key finding is that such large cuts are extremely unlikely under the standard model specification, primarily due to the inherent inertia embedded in the Taylor rule. When we assume a non-inertial version of the Taylor rule, a 100 basis point cut in 2025 can be achieved with a relatively modest shock. However, in recent decades, the Federal Reserve has only adopted non-inertial policy responses in the context of recessions.
Achieving the cuts via lower growth
As a reminder, the current FRB-US baseline projects a single rate cut in 2025 (see reference here). Figure 1 illustrates the projected paths of real GDP growth and the federal funds rate under the baseline scenario (red line), along with three alternative scenarios in which growth is deliberately shocked to generate varying magnitudes of rate cuts in 2025. Specifically, the blue line corresponds to a scenario that produces a 50 basis point cut, the green line to a 75 basis point cut, and the purple line to a 100 basis point cut.
As expected, all scenarios involve a substantial increase in the unemployment rate. In the 50 basis point scenario (blue line), the unemployment rate reaches 5% by Q4 2025, and rises significantly further in the more aggressive shock scenarios (particularly in the purple line).
The key takeaway from this exercise is that, within the model, achieving cuts of 75 or 100 basis points in 2025 is quite difficult. This is due to the high degree of inertia embedded in the Taylor rule, which features an inertial coefficient of 0.85.
Figure 1. FRB-US baseline and lower growth scenarios
Achieving the cuts via lower inflation
In this second set of scenarios, the desired magnitude of rate cuts is achieved by exogenously lowering core inflation. (For the record: real GDP in these scenarios evolves endogenously and there is no recession in the lowest inflation scenario, as the FF rate supports growth). In these simulations, the green lines represent the 50 basis point cut scenario, the grey lines correspond to the 75 basis point scenario, and the purple lines illustrate the 100 basis point scenario.
According to the FRB-US model, a 50 basis point cut in 2025 is feasible, but only under the assumption that year-over-year core PCE inflation falls to 2.5% by December 2025. In contrast, a 100 basis point reduction would require core inflation to decline below the 2% target by the end of this year.
Figure 2. FRB-US baseline and lower inflation scenarios
A simple way of thinking about the dynamics of the model
Is there a simple way to conceptualize the Federal Reserve’s reaction function in the FRB-US model? Yes, there is.
The Taylor rule embedded in FRB-US responds one-for-one to deviations in inflation and the output gap—eventually. The operative word here is eventually, as shocks to short-term measures of inflation, such as month-over-month (MoM) or quarter-over-quarter (QoQ) changes in core PCE, take time to meaningfully influence the year-over-year (YoY) inflation rate. In turn, it is the YoY measure that gradually feeds into the federal funds rate projection. And this gradual transmission mechanism explains why the model does not overreact to one—or sometimes even several—monthly inflation prints.
A non-inertial Fed
What if the Federal Reserve were to adopt a non-inertial Taylor rule? To begin, it is important to note that there is currently no evidence suggesting that the Fed has reduced the degree of inertia in its reaction function—indeed, Chair Powell’s recent comments (just ten days ago) were broadly interpreted as hawkish. Nevertheless, we have simulated such a scenario by applying the same shocks to real GDP growth used in the earlier set of simulations.
As before, the red line represents the model baseline, while the other lines depict alternative scenarios designed to generate 50, 75, and 100 basis point cuts in 2025 under a non-inertial policy rule.
The key result is that, under a non-inertial Taylor rule, a 100 basis point cut in 2025 becomes feasible. In fact, by front-loading the policy response, the FRB-US model suggests that the economy can avoid a recession, with the unemployment rate remaining below 5%.
Figure 3. A non-inertial FRB-US scenarios
Conclusion
If the FOMC maintains its current reaction function, the model simulations are unambiguous: achieving 75 or 100 basis points of rate cuts in 2025 is extremely difficult—indeed, nearly impossible—under current conditions. This is primarily due to inflation remaining elevated and the high degree of inertia embedded in the Fed’s policy rule.
By contrast, assuming either a recession or a shift to a non-inertial policy rule—which, in practice, tend to coincide, as the FOMC has historically abandoned inertia only in recessionary environments—does allow for the magnitude of cuts under consideration. However, at this stage, the model offers little justification for forecasting a recession, given the current data, and we see limited evidence that the FOMC is prepared to shift its reaction function. More time and additional data are needed before such a judgment can be made with confidence. Finally, as mentioned in previous communication we think it is possible to see a jusgmental call by Powell in September if the data cooperates (that is, if core PCE prints 0.2% and the Urate moves at or above 4.4%) but we remain unsure about the odds of this scenario given our own forecast.