An update on the latest FOMC participants’ statements on inflation and possible path for monetary policy.
In the last few days, Clarida, Bostic, and Daly joined the list of FOMC participants who have either explicitly advocated for or have opened to the possibility of a faster tapering.
What to keep in mind
The October CPI report was an eye opener for most FOMC participants who now think the Fed is a bit behind the curve.
At this point, we think the Fed staff and Powell himself are open to discussing the possibility of a faster tapering which should take place already at the December meeting. Nevertheless, we do not expect any announcement at the December meeting because it would be too early. Having said so, as mentioned in another email, we think that the probability of announcing a faster tapering at the January meeting have increased substantially.
Back in September we argued for a fast tapering to be announced and implemented starting in September/October. Then in November we argued in favor of a hawkish/fast tapering. In the end, the FOMC went for an ultra-dovish solution and most participants are now realizing the mistake. Fortunately, we think it is still not too late and, as mentioned, we expect the FOMC to correct the mistake rather soon in order to buy optionality for 2022.
FOMC-meter
According to our “FOMC-meter”, 5 FOMC members have recently expressed dovish statements, 6 participants have expressed neutral statements, and 5 members (out of which only 2 with voting power) have expressed hawkish statements. As usual in the Table below, most recent statements are reported in blue.
Dovish
Jerome H. Powell
Leal Brainard
Charles Evans
John Williams
Neel Kashkari
Neutral
Richard H. Clarida
Randal K. Quarles
MIchelle W. Bowman
Thomas I. Barkin
Mary C. Daly
Loretta J. Mester
Hawkish
Christopher Waller
Raphael Bostic
James Bullard
Patrick T. Harker
Esther L. George
Note: 2021 FOMC voters are bolded.
Recent FOMC participants' statements
Jerome H. Powell – Chair – Dovish
Nov 3 – Fed Powell: Federal Reserve is not behind the curve. In his prepared speech, Powell said that “it remains the case that the drivers of higher inflation have been predominantly connected to the dislocation caused by the pandemic. Specifically, the effects on supply and demand from the shutdowns, the uneven reopening, and the on-going effect of the virus effect. […] Our tools cannot ease the supply constraints. […] We continue to believe that our dynamic economy will adjust to the supply and demand imbalances and that as it does, inflation will decline to much closer 2 percent target. As for inflation being transitory, Powell stressed two things: 1) The Fed has a dual mandate; the current level of inflation is not consistent with price stability but the labor market is not at full employment and 2) the word “transitory” means different things to different people (for some, it means “short-lived”, while for the Fed it means it will not leave a permanent print on inflation rate).
Richard H. Clarida – Vice Chair – Neutral
Nov 19 – Clarida Says Fed May Discuss Taper Pace at December Meeting. “I’ll be looking closely at the data that we get between now and the December meeting, and it may well be appropriate at that meeting to have a discussion about increasing the pace at which we’re reducing our balance sheet,” he said at an event hosted by the San Francisco Fed.
Nov 8 – Clarida continues to believe inflation is transitory. In a prepared remarks at Brookings, Clarida said: “Although in a number of sectors of the economy the imbalances between demand and supply—including labor supply—are substantial, I do continue to judge that these imbalances are likely to dissipate over time as the labor market and global supply chains eventually adjust and, importantly, do so without putting persistent upward pressure on price inflation and wage gains adjusted for productivity.” As for expectations, Clarida said: “and so long as inflation expectations remain well anchored at the 2 percent longer-run goal—which, based on the Fed staff’s common inflation expectations (CIE) index, I judge at present to be the case”. Finally, regarding hiking: “While we are clearly a ways away from considering raising interest rates, if the outlooks for inflation and unemployment I summarized a moment ago turn out to be the actual outcomes realized over the forecast horizon, then I believe that these three necessary conditions for raising the target range for the federal funds rate will have been met by year-end 2022”.
Randal K. Quarles – Vice Chair – Neutral
Oct 20 – Fed Quarles thinks that the FOMC is not behind the curve. “I think it is clear that we have met the test of substantial further progress toward both our employment and our inflation mandates, and I would support a decision at our November meeting to start reducing these purchases and complete that process by the middle of next year.”, he said. “Supply constraints in production and distribution already have become more widespread and have lasted longer than most forecasters anticipated. As noted earlier, labor supply constraints are making it difficult for businesses to keep up with demand. This dynamic will continue to support robust wage growth, putting further upward pressure on prices. Moreover, there is evidence in the past couple of months that a broader range of prices are beginning to increase at moderate rates, and I am closely watching those developments.” […] “I am among those who see a good chance that inflation will remain above 2 percent next year, but I am not quite ready to conclude that this “transitory” period is already “too long.” “. “I do not see the FOMC as behind the curve, for three reasons: Most of the biggest drivers of the very high current inflation rates will ease in coming quarters, some measures of underlying inflation pressures are less worrisome, and longer-term inflation expectations are anchored, at least for now.”. “Going forward, the question is not only whether inflation will fall in the coming months, but also how far it will fall and if it will fall soon enough to avoid spurring a concerning rise in longer-term inflation expectations.”. However, “If inflation does remain more than moderately above 2 percent, be assured that the FOMC has the framework and the tools to address it.”
Lael Brainard – Governor – Dovish
Sep 27 – Fed’s Brainard says currently elevated level of inflation is driven by COVID-related disruptions. In a prepared speech, Brainard said she expects inflation to decelerate, and pre-COVID inflation dynamics to return when COVID disruptions dissipate. She also added that “with Delta disrupting the rotation from goods to services and prolonging supply bottlenecks, it is uncertain just how fast and how much inflation will decelerate over the remainder of the year and into next year”. As for inflation expectations, Brainard said that “I am vigilant for any signs that the current high level of inflation might push longer-term inflation expectations above levels consistent with our 2 percent inflation objective. Market-based measures of inflation compensation suggest inflation expectations remain well anchored. For instance, the five-year, five-year-forward CPI inflation compensation measure based on Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities has remained range bound around 2.2 percent since declining about 0.2 percentage point in June—consistent with the FOMC’s 2 percent objective for PCE inflation.” Finaly, she concluded that “There are good reasons to expect a return to pre-COVID inflation dynamics due to the underlying structural features of a relatively flat Phillips curve, low equilibrium interest rates, and low underlying trend inflation. While the playbook for guiding inflation back down to target following a moderate overshoot is well tested and effective, experience suggests it is difficult to guide inflation up to target from below”.
Christopher J. Waller – Governor – Hawkish
Nov 19 – Fed’s Waller: Fed needs faster taper, more rapid liftoff in interest rates. “Due to a combining of those supply constraints with strong demand, inflation pressures are becoming more widespread and may last longer into 2022 than I thought they would. These factors haven’t dented my optimism that the strong recovery will continue but they have raised the risks that supply constraints may limit job gains and output growth, and that inflation may complicate the FOMC’s management of monetary policy in 2022.” […] “inflation has escalated substantially this year, along with a significant rise in inflation expectations.” […] “Even trimmed mean measures of inflation that exclude some big price increases, such as the Cleveland Fed and the Dallas Fed measures, report inflation rates above the Fed’s 2 percent target. Diffusion indexes of price changes, which are often useful in detecting turning points in the data, show an increasing number of categories with 3 or 12-month inflation exceeding 3 percent, compared with earlier this year.”. “I expect that these pressures are related to both supply constraints, which may be beginning to improve, and strong demand, which shows no sign of abating” […] “To me, the inflation data are starting to look a lot more like a big snowfall that will stay on the ground for a while, and that development is affecting my expectations of the level of monetary accommodation that is needed going forward.”. ” if the economy makes quick progress toward maximum employment or inflation data show no signs of retreating from their currently high readings, the Committee may choose to speed up the taper, which would position it to accelerate subsequent steps in tightening monetary policy if necessary. The timing of any policy action is a decision for the FOMC, but for my part the rapid improvement in the labor market and the deteriorating inflation data have pushed me towards favoring a faster pace of tapering and a more rapid removal of accommodation in 2022.” […] “I believe the condition [for lift-off] for inflation has been met and we are making great strides towards achieving the employment leg of our mandate. I will be looking at the incoming data to determine when we have achieved both these criteria.”
Michelle W. Bowman – Governor – Neutral
Nov 5 – Fed Board Bowman sees housing inflation adding pressure to overall price inflation. “There are signs of underlying supply and demand imbalances that will contribute to increases in housing costs and inflation” she said adding that “I anticipate that these housing supply issues are unlikely to reverse materially in the short term, which suggests that we are likely to see higher inflation from housing for a while.”
Oct 13 – Fed Board Bowman sees inflation as transitory but says that bottlencks could take time so solve. “Earlier this year, as the economy was reopening, we saw a pronounced pickup in inflation, as prices for motor vehicles, electronics, and other goods rose especially rapidly” “We are seeing shipments at record levels, and more capacity is expected to come on line, but the combination of strong demand and intermittent disruptions to this complex supply chain poses a risk that it could be some time before semiconductor supply issues are resolved.”. As for additional risks around the forecast, Bowman said that one “source of inflation risk comes from the lower labor force participation, which, as I mentioned earlier, has led some firms to offer inducements to bring potential workers back, including hiring bonuses and higher wages. Even with these incentives, however, many firms are struggling with staffing, and some are also offering training programs for new hires to develop required job skills. Wage increases and these additional employee investments are increasing firms’ costs, potentially adding to inflationary pressures.”
Thomas I. Barkin – Richmond Fed President – Neutral
Nov 15 – Barkin says Fed needs ‘a few more months’ to see clear picture of inflation. “It may take several more months at least for the Federal Reserve to understand if high inflation and labor shortages are offshoots of the pandemic that will eventually ease, or reflect more durable changes to the economy”, Richmond Federal Reserve President Thomas Barkin said.
Oct 22 – Fed Barkin favors finishing taper before considering rate hike. “My preference would be to finish tapering before you look to rates”, he said. “You do not want to be doing both at the same time. It is a real mixed messag
Raphael Bostic – Atlanta Fed President – Hawkish
Nov 23 – Fed’s Bostic says good arguments can be made to consider a faster taper. “It is appropriate to us to be talking about the pace of tapering and being open to a faster one,” Bostic said.The Atlanta Fed president said he expected further strong inflation readings. If the employment numbers come in equally strong, “I think the case would be much stronger for a faster taper,” he said. Regarding interest-rate moves, Bostic said he has felt for several months that it would be appropriate to raise short-term interest rates once during 2022.
Nov 18 – Fed’s Bostic: could start normalizing interest rates next summer. “Right now, our projections suggest that by the summertime of next year, the number of jobs that we have in the economy will be pretty much where we were pre-pandemic,” Bostic said in an interview. “And at that point, I think it’s appropriate for us to try to normalize
Mary C. Daly – San Francisco Fed President – Neutral
Nov 24 – Fed Daly Says Taper Could Be Accelerated. “If the job market continues to perform well and inflation rises, the taper could be accelerated” Daly said. “It is too early to call for a taper acceleration today; more information is required”. She also added that “the decision on purchasing assets differs from the decision to raise interest rates”. “The fed will want to hike rates before the end of 2022. Even if the fed raises rates a few times next year, it will continue to provide accommodation. […] It would not surprise me in the least if there were one or two rate increases next year.” Finally, she said that “Wage inflation has been higher than average, but there is no evidence of a wage price spiral.”
Nov 16 – Fed’s Daly warns against pre-emptive interest rate hikes to cool inflation. “I have a strong bias toward continuing taper at the current pace. Following tapering, the next step is forward guidance, which should be more in line with the economic outlook. Inflation is a real problem and it is weighing on consumers. […] The magnitude and persistence of these readings has come as a surprise, but it’s actually not that mysterious. Standard theory tells us that inflation occurs when demand outstrips supply and prices rise to adjust. Uncertainty over the next 6-9 months is high, not just for us economy but across the world. I expect to have more clarity on the economy by next summer. […] Given the factors boosting prices that I’ve just described, I expect a moderation in price pressures as the pandemic recedes. Consumers will likely pivot back to their normal bundles of goods and services—spending some time with their new home entertainment centers, but also going to movies, concerts, dinners and, hopefully, holiday parties.” Daly said.
Charles L. Evans – Chicago Fed President – Dovish
Nov 18 – Fed’s Evans says may need 2022 rate hike. Chicago Federal Reserve President Charles Evans, one of the U.S. central bank’s most reliable policy doves, said he is “open-minded” to adjustments in monetary policy next year, if inflation continues to stay high. That’s not, he said, his expectation, given his view that price pressures will ease next year as supply chains get repaired and consumer demand now concentrated on goods shifts to services in what would be a return to a more normal economic balance. “It might be a gentle increase; it could begin next year after we finish our asset purchasing program, or it could be as long as into 2023; it will depend on the data that we see and the state of inflationary pressures”. Evans said
Nov 8 – Fed’s Evans: inflation rise is ‘temporary,’ but sees upside risk. “I had expected to see more progress by now,” Evans said in remarks prepared for delivery to the Original Equipment Suppliers Association, adding that there are signs that inflationary pressures may be building more broadly, including increases in rents. “These developments deserve careful monitoring and present a greater upside risk to my inflation outlook than I had thought last summer.”
John C. Williams – New York Fed President – Dovish
Sep 27 – Fed’s Williams predicts the high rate of inflation this year will cool to 2 percent in 2022. Williams pointed to ongoing shortages in labor and business supplies as a big contributor in the sharp increase in inflation this year as companies have had to pay more for wages and materials, leading to higher prices for a variety of products. Although inflation is now well above the Fed’s 2% target, Williams said he expects price pressures to ease as the pandemic fades and business returns close to normal. Yet he admitted the outlook is uncertain and he didn’t put a precise timetable on when inflation would return to the 2% range.
James Bullard – St. Louis Fed President – Hawkish
Nov 16 – Fed’s Bullard says Fed should tack “hawkish” in next couple of meetings. “If inflation happens to go away we are in great shape for that. If inflation doesn’t go away as quickly as many are currently anticipating it is going to be up to the (Federal Open Market Committee) to keep inflation under control,” Bullard said. Inflation at the current levels “does not have the reputation of moving down very easily,” Mr. Bullard said. “I think it behooves the [Federal Open Market Committee] to tack in a more hawkish direction in the next couple of meetings so that we’re managing the risk of inflation appropriately.” Bullard said the FOMC could speed up the taper if appropriate, which would allow the Committee to assess the data a bit earlier and decide what to do on the policy rate. He discussed other considerations for policy if needed, including playing up the idea that raising the policy rate wouldn’t have to wait until the end of the taper, and allowing runoff of the balance sheet at the end of the taper instead of waiting on that decision for a while.
Nov 8 – Fed’s Bullard says he sees two rate hikes in 2022. “If inflation is more persistent than we are saying right now, then I think we may have to take a little sooner action in order to keep inflation under control,” Bullard said in an interview on Fox Business Network. Asked if the Fed could then raise rates three or four times next year, Bullard said “that is not my base case right now.” The Fed has already “done a lot to move the policy in a more hawkish direction,” he said, with the Fed’s plan to pare its asset purchases, announced last week, starting earlier and projected to end sooner than had been anticipated just six months earlier.”
Esther L. George – Kansas City Fed President – Hawkish
Nov 5 – Fed George says monetary policy should not over-react. In a prepared speech, George said: “First, monetary policy should look through temporary increases in inflation.” […] “Given the frequency of temporary shocks to energy and commodity price inflation that are often attributed to supply, core inflation is likely to offer a better measure of underlying or trend inflation and thus is thought to provide an important guide to monetary policy.” […] “Monetary policy should not respond aggressively to increases in inflation resulting from a shift in relative prices” […] “Theory suggests it is better for policymakers to accept this increase in inflation, which should be temporary, than to tighten policy and restrict overall activity in an effort to force offsetting price declines in shrinking sectors.”
Patrick T. Harker – Philadelphia Fed President – Hawkish
Nov 8 – Fed’s Harker says inflation is more widespread across products and services than it was earlier this year. ” In the third quarter, nearly three-quarters of spending on goods and services in the CPI “basket” was on goods that displayed annualized inflation of more than 4 percent; in the second quarter, tht was true for only a little more than a third of the goods and services that comprise the basket” he said. He also added that “we are monitoring inflation very closely and are prepared to take action, should circumstances warrant it”.
Neel Kashkari – Minneapolis – Dovish
Nov 15 – Fed’s Kashkari expects higher inflation continuing over next few months. Minneapolis Federal Reserve Bank President Neel Kashkari said on Sunday he expects higher inflation continuing over the next few months but warned that the U.S. central bank should not overreact to elevated inflation as it is likely to be temporary.
Nov 9 – Fed’s Kashkari: next nine months key for getting clarity on economic outlook. “I’m optimistic, in the next three, six, nine months we will get a lot more information,” and clarity about the outlook for both inflation and the labor market, he said.
Loretta J. Mester – Cleveland Fed President – Neutral
Oct 20 – Fed Mester Says No Rate Hike ‘Any Time Soon,’ Watching Inflation. “The thought about raising interest rates is not a near-term consideration at all,” she told CNBC television in an interview. “We’re going to think about the decision coming up, which is about the asset purchases, and then as those wind down we’ll have time to assess where the economy is.” “I don’t think that interest rate hikes are coming any time soon because I don’t think we’ll reach our goals which are maximum employment and inflation at and above 2% for some time,” Mester said. “So far the medium-run inflation expectations and longer-run inflation expectations are still at levels consistent with our 2% inflation goal,” she said. “We don’t want to get into a situation where they continue to move up because that would be a signal that we may have to do an adjustment.” “If we are still seeing 4% inflation or in that area next spring, then I think we might have to reassess the speed with which we would be thinking about raising interest rates,” she said.