We have updated our “Pre September 2022 Meeting Package” following the August CPI/PPI reports.
Please, find below the updated models outputs and our comment.
To keep in mind
The incoming data on August CPI/PPI prices triggered revisions to our models estimates and forecasts. The “main” model forecast (conditional on the FF rate peaking at 4% or alternatively the unemployment rate reaching 4.1%-4.2%) is now above 3% in 2024 and just a touch lower in 2025 (2.9%). Measures of trend inflation (which can be taken as an estimate of future medium-term inflation) are also around 3%.
In other words, the models are signaling significant upside risks around the Fed staff (and SEP) forecasts, especially in 2023 and 2024.
This implies that either (i) the September SEP will signal a peak of the FF rate at 4% but might show significant upward revisions to the core PCE price inflation forecast in 2023 and 2024, or (ii) it might show a higher FF rate path (and a smaller upward revisions to the inflation forecast). In our view, other signals in the upcoming SEP would not be internally consistent or would ignore the reality of the data.
Which way the FOMC will go depends on their updated relative preference (the coefficients of the unemployment gap in their reaction function). If they do not care about raising the unemployment rate in this moment, they might signal a peak of the FF rate well above 4%.
The Fed staff core PCE forecast
According to the July FOMC minutes, the Fed staff expected core PCE price inflation to be 4.0% in 2022, 2.6% in 2023, and 2.0% in 2024 (minutes: “Total PCE price inflation was expected to be 4.8 percent in 2022, and core inflation was expected to be 4.0 percent. Core PCE price inflation was expected to step down to 2.6 percent in 2023 and to 2.0 percent in 2024”).
By reverse engineering the Fed staff forecast, we concluded that the staff expected core PCE prices to expand around 68bps (cumulative) in July and August (see our Pre July FOMC Meeting package). The incoming data since the closing day of the July meeting have been close to the Fed staff expectations, as a downward surprise in July was offset by an upward surprise in August.
Nevertheless, as we mentioned yesterday, in our view the narrative and the strength of the August CPI data have forced the Fed staff to revise up its near-term forecast. For this reason, we think the Fed staff will revise up its 2022 forecast to 4.1%-4.2%. At the same time, in our view, the Fed staff will not materially change its 2023/2024 forecast (explaining why is beyond the scope of this note and we might circulate an ad-hoc one soon).
Having said so, as explained below, the biggest issue is the gap between the Fed staff (and SEP) forecast in 2023-2024 and the “main” model -> see next section.
“Main” Phillips curve model
Given the August CPI/PPI reports, we now expect core PCE prices to grow 4.3% in 2022:Q3. The Q3 nowcast is about half of a percentage point higher than before the CPI/PPI releases.
Conditional on the new information set, our “main” Phillips curve model expects core PCE price inflation (Q4/Q4) at 4.4% in 2022, 3.5% in 2023, and 3.2% in 2024, and 2.9% in 2025.
Comparing the main model to the SEP, the Fed staff and the NY Fed DSGE model forecasts
Following the evolution of the forecast can be challenging. For this reason, we have prepared 3 charts showing the evolution of the core PCE price inflation forecast. Each chart refers to a different year (Q4/Q4, %): 2022, 2023, and 2024. In each chart we show the evolution of our “main” Phillips curve model forecast compared to the SEP, the Fed staff forecast as inferred from the FOMC minutes, and the NY Fed DSGE model. The dates on the x-axis refer to the corresponding FOMCs.
Three conclusions emerge. First, the “main” model forecast (the black line) tends to anticipate the other forecasts (see 2022 chart). Second, the “main” model is signaling some small upside risks in 2022 but large risks in 2023 and 2024. Finally, conditional on the expected path of the FF rate (which feeds into the different forecasts, one way or the other), core inflation is not converging back to target at the end of the forecast horizon.
For this reason, we conclude that the 4% FF rate signaled by most FOMC participants is a lower bound estimate. There is a world in which the Fed raises the FF rate to 4% and keeps it there for several quarters but it must accept a core inflation rate above 3%. Therefore, in our view and estimates, the likely scenario is now that the Fed will not stop at 4% (see last section of this note).
Trend models
The August CPI has triggered an upward revision to the estimates of trend inflation. The average of our set of 11 trend models is at 2.8% in 2022:Q3, one tenth higher than last round (and last quarter). The average of the models continues to trend higher and might take few other quarters before levelling out. All told, a reasonable estimate of trend inflation can be placed at 3% right now. By construction, trend inflation is persistent and can be taken as an indication of the level at which inflation will land in the medium-term.
Note: the chart shows the estimated trend inflation from 11 econometric models. The models are split into three groups. The first group is a collection of Phillips-curve (PC) type of trend inflation models in which a measure of long-term inflation expectations is used as a proxy of trend inflation. The second group is a collection of state-space unobserved component models in which we have modelled trend inflation either as a smooth trend or as an augmented local level. Finally, the third group of models is a collection of Time Varying Parameters Vector AutoRegressive models (TVP-VAR) with different endogenous variables. This set of models follows the FEDS Note by Rudd (2020) “Underlying Inflation: Its Measurement and Significance”. The Fed staff assumption about the level of underlying inflation (set at 1.8 percent) is inferred from Laubach et al. (2014) “Long-term Inflation Expectations and Risks to the Inflation Outlook“.
Note: the 70% confidence intervals refer to 2022:Q2. The “Average” line is calculated as a simple mean across all models.
Taylor rules
We have also updated our Taylor rules, based on the new trajectory of core PCE price inflation. As usual, the Fed staff (2021) rule (the red line in the chart below) is calibrated to match the latest dots plot (that is, conditional on the latest SEP projections, we have set the inertia parameter so that the red line matched the dots plot after the June meeting). Based on that, we have fed the Fed staff (2021) rule and the other rules with the new forecasts.
Conditional on the new forecasts, the FF rate peaks a bit above 4%: 4.2% using the Fed staff (2021) rule and 4.3% using the inertial Taylor (1999) rule.
IMPORTANT: the results shown in the chart below are conditional not only on the inertial parameter but on other parameters of the Taylor rule. Probably the most important one at the moment is the coefficient of the unemployment gap (“how much the FOMC cares about labor markets”). In the extreme case in which the FOMC only cares about inflation, the trajectory of the FF rate is of course higher than in the baseline (depending on the calibration, the FF rate can peak as high as 4.5%-5%).