As a preamble, you can find two interviews with Riccardo Trezzi in The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times, covering his views ahead of the FOMC meeting and his assessment of the Committee’s policy decision, respectively, at the two links below.
WSJ: Fed Holds Rates Steady But Two Officials Sought Another Increase
NYT: The Fed Is Expected to Hold Rates Steady. Warsh Will Have to Explain Why.
Is the Fed really committed to bringing inflation back to target? Did Warsh explain why the Fed did not hike today? NO and NO.
Is the Federal Reserve genuinely committed to bringing inflation back to its 2% target? And if so, why did it decide not to raise interest rates after monthly core PCE inflation reached 34-37 basis points, equivalent to an annualized rate above 4%? This simple question was at the heart of today’s FOMC meeting, which we had expected to deliver a hawkish hold, with the Committee leaving rates unchanged while maintaining a distinctly hawkish tone and demonstrating its commitment to disinflating the U.S. economy.
From our perspective, the outcome was deeply disappointing. The new statement makes little economic sense, for the reasons discussed below, and the decision to emphasize the need to accumulate more information is particularly difficult to justify. A central bank should aim to reduce uncertainty while recognizing that its own policy decisions influence future economic outcomes. The repeated argument that more information is needed overlooks the endogeneity of monetary policy and raises serious questions about the Committee’s reaction function.
More importantly, during the press conference, Warsh devoted remarkably little attention to the unfavorable inflation data received since September and failed, in our view, to provide a convincing explanation for leaving rates unchanged. This is particularly puzzling given that the statement itself acknowledges that “economic activity is expanding at a strong pace,” confirming that the U.S. economy remains remarkably resilient. Overall, we consider both the FOMC statement and Warsh’s performance seriously inadequate. Policymakers appear far too relaxed about recent inflation developments, to the point that they seem increasingly unable to explain their decisions consistently.
Consider the evolution of Fed communication. In June, the Committee appeared determined to pursue a hawkish stance. In July, it unexpectedly turned dovish, only to become hawkish again in September. Today, we heard virtually nothing genuinely hawkish, with the press conference sounding, if anything, rather dovish. These abrupt changes have generated considerable uncertainty and increasingly give the impression of a Federal Reserve conducting monetary policy on a discretionary basis. For economists, discretion is a particularly troubling concept in central banking because it undermines credibility, makes the reaction function unpredictable, and weakens the ability to commit consistently to price stability.
In our view, today’s meeting represents a significant step backward. It has added confusion without clarifying whether the Fed is genuinely committed to bringing inflation back to target. We can only hope that the Committee will eventually articulate a coherent policy strategy and demonstrate through its actions that restoring price stability remains its priority.
Statement
In our view, the new FOMC statement makes little sense, particularly because of the addition of the following sentence, “The accumulation of more information will help the Committee determine the policy stance appropriate to ensure a timely return of inflation to the Committee’s 2 percent goal.”
We find this argument difficult to justify for two reasons. First, one can always argue that more time and additional information are needed to assess incoming economic data, making this an essentially open ended justification for postponing policy decisions. More importantly, however, the statement overlooks a fundamental issue in monetary economics, namely the endogeneity of the Fed’s own policy actions. The Federal Reserve itself, through its monetary policy decisions, influences the future evolution of the very economic variables it claims to need more information about. From this perspective, the Fed should clarify its reaction function and conduct monetary policy consistently with that function, rather than relying on discretionary decisions justified by the repeated need to accumulate more information. The incoming data are themselves partly endogenous to the policy stance chosen by the Committee, and treating them as if they were independent of monetary policy is conceptually problematic.
For these reasons, we regard the new statement as a significant step backward, both in terms of the clarity of the Fed’s communication and, more fundamentally, the economic logic underlying its policy framework.
Q&As
Question: Why not hiking today?
Warsh. “So it’s a good question. I will say, read your stories the last day or two, so I must admit I sort of saw that question coming. What I said in my prepared statement was information coming in the coming period will help us tell us where we want to be. But I suspect you want a little more than that. So let me, let me give it a shot.
Ensuring price stability, Colby, quashing inflation is not about some fixed individual date on a calendar. Same way it’s not about some isolated data point. If it were about those two things, this job would be easier and we wouldn’t be suffering from nearly six years of inflation above target.
So what’s this about? It’s about ensuring we have clear objectives and it’s about a monetary policy strategy which might sound in your ear and others like a change from the last several years.
So let me step back. In the five months or so that I’ve been around, we’ve put in place what I describe as new monetary medicine. What’s been in that package of medicine?
First thing we did when we showed up with my colleagues is we doubled down on the 2% inflation target. We said we own it. We’re taking responsibility for it. And if you think that we’re tolerating some inflation target somewhere in the twos, let us disabuse you of it. That was the first part of this new monetary medicine.
Second part is we took responsibility. No anguish of central banking here, no blaming others.
It’s the third thing that we’ve done. We laid out for you and the world our framework. I did it in Jackson Hole. It was part of the discussion the last couple days. It’s the framework that many of my colleagues hew to as well. This is how we think about how monetary policy should work. These are the transmission mechanisms and this is how we’re going to deliver.
Then what do we do? We interrogate reality. We do that periodically. That’s a very useful thing to do. But we don’t just talk, we act. And so in September when we last met, we acted. We removed a dose of accommodation.
So what are the signposts about how this new strategy is going? Inflation compensation as measured by swaps prices, many other measures, inflation compensation is going in the right way. Inflation expectations. The world is quite unsettled. If you’d say absent the Fed, what would have happened to expectations? They might have gone the wrong way. They’ve gone the right way too. So I feel good about those signposts.
The period right in front of us is information rich. There is a lot that’s happening in the world. My colleagues and I are keen to take notice of it.
So in this coming period, what do I think we’re going to be able to do? We’re going to be able to figure out what’s the appropriate protocol as part of this package that we start to deliver five months ago to deliver price stability.
I’m encouraged by the progress we’ve made in a short period of time. But if the crux of your question is you haven’t delivered yet, you haven’t achieved price stability, you’re right about that. But we’re working on it.”
Comment: A lot of words, indeed. And yet, after all that, we still do not understand why the Fed decided not to raise interest rates. More importantly, notice that Warsh was unable to point to any meaningful progress in the price inflation data, for the simple reason that there has been none.
As we argued above when discussing the new FOMC statement, Warsh’s explanation makes little economic sense. To us, it increasingly sounds as though the Fed has effectively adopted a discretionary approach to monetary policy, and unfortunately, we regard this as a very troubling development.
Question: Strong demand component in inflation on top of supply right now?
Warsh. “Good, good, good pickup of that. Good team effort. So, so I’d say this. The only things we really know in economics and supply and demand cross. Our measures of the size and the shape of the aggregate demand curve is imperfect.
Broadly what I heard in the room the last couple of days is consistent with my own views, which is the economy is strong. I didn’t try to sugarcoat that in the first part of my statement. The economy has been marked up for the first three quarters. The economy is pointing in the right direction.
Is the economy running too hot? Is the economy running too strong? That isn’t a judgment of most of my colleagues. Part of it is we never know what potential growth really is, Howard. My judgment is we have seen an improvement in productivity. We can’t measure it precisely. I think most of that change in productivity precedes everything we’re talking about super intelligence.
But productivity has been moving higher in the economy, however imperfectly measured, I think for a couple of years. And so economic growth is higher, but that doesn’t tell me that economic growth is somehow causing inflation and making our job harder. But we’ll be continuing to look at those issues.
The goal in my view, and you’ve heard me say this before, isn’t to throw sand in the gears of the economy and throw people out of work. I don’t think we have to do that. The dominant means in which this policy is going to be put into practice is we are tightening financial conditions. They’ve tightened a bit since we met last time. That isn’t something that we’re uncomfortable with. That tells me that policy is working. And I think we can do that and make the economy more durable, have it last longer, and still achieve stable prices.”
Comment: First, we are not even sure that this is still the appropriate question to ask at this stage. Of course, distinguishing between demand and supply shocks matters, and the macroeconomic implications can differ depending on the nature of the shock. However, as the Chair himself acknowledged, we have now experienced almost six years of elevated inflation. At some point, the source of inflation becomes increasingly irrelevant for the conduct of monetary policy.
Moreover, if we think in terms of a standard supply and demand diagram, as Waller himself suggested, even when the initial shock originates entirely on the supply side, the economy still moves along a demand curve. Higher prices, even following a purely adverse supply shock, can remain persistently elevated only if demand conditions remain sufficiently accommodative to sustain them.
After almost six years of elevated inflation, and with a substantial investment boom currently underway, we therefore find the distinction between demand and supply shocks increasingly unhelpful for assessing the appropriate monetary policy response. From our perspective, whether the latest shock is predominantly driven by demand or supply matters relatively little at this stage.