Unconvincingly good
Today’s core PCE price inflation is “unconvincingly good”, as the positive aggregate number (2% at annual rate) masks a distribution that is more stable than in CPI space. The Fed, in our view, needs more convincing evidence. November is one of those (rare) months in which the evidence of the models is mixed; there is good news, but there is evidence of “residual” strength in the data.
The good news is that the common component of the CI-C model was soft and trending down. However, the median of the distribution moved sideways and remained well above pre-Covid levels (as opposed to CPI space). Also, the clear left shift of the distribution in CPI space is not visible in PCE space, at least not yet. This is partially due to non-market prices (market-based core PCE grew 1% at annual rate in November), and in part to some strength. All told: we are making baby-steps progress but the evidence that inflation will return towards target remains unconvincing. In our view, the Fed will need more convincing evidence that this disinflation is genuine before changing tone.
Evidence from the distributions
This month, most percentiles ticked down but the median moved sideways. As such, it is hard to take a lot of signals from the percentiles because the evidence suggests that about half of the distribution was about stable. Put it differently, there are small progresses but before making hard calls, the median must return to its pre-Covid levels. We are not there yet.
Percentiles details:
- The 5th pct is -30.2% (from -25.5%)
- The 10th pct is -24.5% (from -16.6%)
- The 25th pct is -5.2% (from -4.6%)
- The 50th pct is 3.1% (from 3.0%)
- The 75th pct is 8.4% (from 10.0%)
- The 90th pct is 20.9% (from 21.5%)
- The 95th pct is 24.4% (from 35.4%)
The distribution of the last 3 months (Figure 1) is similar to the previous months, not a good sign. In the last 3 months, core PCE prices grew at an average monthly pace of 30bps, below the 42bps of the previous three months and the 35bps of the 6 to 9 months ago period. However, Figure 1 shows that the distribution of the last three months is pretty similar to recent history, especially excluding the tails. This is the main reason why, in our view, it is still too early to make hard calls and we would not be surprised to see higher core PCE price readings going forward. In a nutshell: the disinflation road is bumpy and it takes time to make sure the job is done.
Evidence from our CI-C model
Our CI-C model estimates that net of Covid and idiosyncratic shocks, the strength of the data in November is losing steam. Figure 5 shows the decomposition of the MoM of CPI excluding food and energy items in the “common” component (the blue bars), the “idiosyncratic” component (the yellow bars), and the “Covid” effect (the green bars). The model estimates that in November the common component increased by 17bps. The Covid effect is estimated small negative (-3bps), and the idiosyncratic shock is small positive (3bps).
This is the good news in today’s report because the common component is estimated soft and the core reading is not driven by negative idiosyncratic shocks.
Today’s reading brings the YoY of the common component to 2.4 percent, a touch lower than the previous months. At the same time, today’s reading brings the 3m/3m a.r. of the common component at 2.3 percent and the 6m/6m a.r. at 2.5 percent (Figure 6). This evidence suggests that the YoY of the common component has peaked and it is now ready to start its descent.
Implications for the medium-term forecast of core PCE price inflation
Today’s PCE reading has no material implications for the medium-term forecast. Using our “main” Phillips curve model, the latest Q4/Q4 forecast is: 3.5% in 2023, 3.3% in 2024, and 3.0% in 2025 (these figures are marginally higher than after the CPI report because of revised assumptions of the exogenous, and not because of the incoming data of core PCE prices).
As mentioned in previous notes, the “main” model is unlikely to send big dovish signals until 2023:Q2.
Note: the figure shows the latest run of our “main” Phillips curve model. The confidence intervals (C.I.) are estimated using quasi-out-of-sample methods (estimate the model over a sub-sample, forecast, and calculate the root mean squared forecast errors). First quarter of forecast: 2023:Q1.
Implications for the Fed Board staff
Today’s PCE reading is a mixed bag. We expect the Fed to continue delivering the message of the December 2022 FOMC meeting.
If we put everything together, we are left with a mixed bag of signals after today’s report. The Fed staff can certainly celebrate the market-based core PCE reading (1% ar), which confirms we are on the right trajectory. But the behavior of the median (stable) and the entire distribution (similar to the previous months) is not good news for the staff/FOMC. In our experience, in the pre-Covid world, the Fed staff would have taken signal from the market-based reading and the evidence of the CI-C model. But the recent experience caution against jumping to strong conclusions, especially because the distribution is more stable than (we) expected.
The data are saying “good news but be careful!”. In our view, the Fed is listening and act accordingly.
Figures – monthly distributions
Figure 2. Percentiles and Standard Deviation of the distribution of MoM changes (PCE prices excluding food and energy items, % a.r.)
Figures – CI-C model
Figure 5. Contributions to MoM changes of PCE excluding food and energy items (CI-C model)
Note: the Figure shows the decomposition of the MoM percent changes of PCE prices excluding food and energy items. The contributions are estimated using our CI-C model, a 2-stage OLS-LASSO regression model. The “Covid” effect is identified with price variations outside the 10th-90th percentiles of each item pre-Covid price change distribution.