PCE is a bit less benign than CPI, but still
We have updated our estimates of (core) PCE price changes distributions to include the month of October 2022. In October, core PCE prices expanded 22bps, just a touch lower than our expectation (25bps) after the CPI and PPI reports. The October reading is heavily influenced by a very soft reading in the volatile component of “non-market prices” which we estimate grew at 0.25% (a.r.). On the other hand, the market-based component of core PCE prices (which tend to be a better predictor of future core PCE prices) grew at 3.7% (a.r.) in October.
Today’s report suggests that the evidence in PCE space is a bit less benign than in CPI space as the median dropped but the entire distribution is broadly similar to the one of 6-9 months ago. This is due to two factors: (i) different items weights in CPI vs PCE, and (ii) the behavior of “non-market” prices which are included only in PCE space.
Today’s report can be taken as a summary of where we are. The near-term data suggest that moderation is on its way. But they also suggest that net of idiosyncratic and special factors, little suggests that inflation will quickly return to 2% soon. Rather, the data continues to suggest inflation will moderate but it will land around 3%-3.5%.
As for the Fed, the Chair has spoken. We took Powell very seriously because in our view he signaled that he is willing to accept the risks around the inflation outlook to soft-land the economy. Powell’s words were uneventful. But what he did not say was significant. Time to adapt to this new phase.
Details
In today’s report:
- All percentiles (excluding the 5th) shifted to the left signaling a genuine disinflation process at work. This is a very strong signal and it should be taken seriously.
- The median dropped to 2.8% a.r. (from 4.0% a.r.) in line with the weighted mean (2.7% a.r.).
- The standard deviation of price changes (Figure 3) increased, driven by the large downward movement in non-market prices.
Percentiles details:
- The 5th pct is -25.4% (from -26.7%)
- The 10th pct is -12.8% (from -16.6%)
- The 25th pct is -4.8% (from -2.4%)
- The 50th pct is 2.8% (from 4.0%)
- The 75th pct is 10.1% (from 11.3%)
- The 90th pct is 21.3% (from 30.6%)
- The 95th pct is 35.4% (from 43.1%)
The most important evidence continues to come from the sequential distributions of the last 9 month (Figure 4) which show important signs of stabilization and disinflation. The Kernels of the last 3 months (black line in Figure 4) is somehow similar to the distribution of 6-9 months ago (red line) but it has a a thicker left shoulder. Not only but if we compare the distribution of the last 3 months to the previous 3 months, we notice a clear thicker left shoulder and less mass in the 0-10 area.
Translated: the long-waited disinflation is finally happening and it should be taken very seriously. For this reason, we reiterate our call: we are in the “plateau” of inflation. The models suggest that raising the FF rate to 5%-ish and keep it there for a few quarters should be enough to disinflate the US economy. Whether that will be enough to return to 2% (rather than lending to 3%) is still unclear.
Implications for the Fed
(Note: based on today’s data, the updated “main” Phillips curve model forecast for core PCE price inflation is: 3.8% in 2023 (Q4/Q4), 3.7% in 2024, and 3.4% in 2025. We will circulate our Pre-December FOMC meeting package in the next few days).
As discussed in private meetings, in our view the Fed staff still cannot bring good news to the FOMC because most models continue to signal upside risks around the medium-term forecast and because at the moment nothing says that inflation will quickly converge back to target. Having said so, from our own point of view (and probably also in Powell’s mind) it is hard to ignore the signals from the distributions. This is not the time to celebrate victory; it will come, eventually. But this is the time to recognize that the Fed has been successful in providing an anchor and stabilizing the distributions. There is now a concrete chance that keeping the rates high (5%-ish FF rate) for 2-3 quarters will be enough to lower inflation to an acceptable level (3%-ish). The risks around this forecast are now balanced and might turn to the downside soon depending on the incoming data.