In this note, we review two new papers, “Navigating by Falling Stars: Monetary Policy with Fiscally Driven Natural Rates” by Rodolfo G. Campos (Bank of Spain), Jesús Fernández-Villaverde (UPenn), Galo Nuno (Bank of Spain), and Peter Paz (Bank of Spain), and “The Macroeconomic Effects of Global Supply Chain Reorientation” by Daragh Clancy (Bank of Ireland), Donal Smith (OECD), and Vilém Valenta (ECB).
The first paper demonstrates that fiscal policy can affect the natural rate in a general class of heterogeneous agent models.The paper provides a new type of monetary-fiscal interaction. The second paper studies the implications of production reshoring in a DSGE model for the Euro area and finds that enforced reduction in import quantity increases inflation along the transition to a new equilibrium and has possible positive effects on long-run output.
Paper #1: Campos et al. (2024)
The paper Navigating by Falling Stars: Monetary Policy with Fiscally Driven Natural Rates by Rodolfo G. Campos (Bank of Spain), Jesús Fernández-Villaverde (UPenn), Galo Nuno (Bank of Spain), and Peter Paz (Bank of Spain) demonstrates that fiscal policy can affect the natural rate in a general class of heterogeneous agent models. The paper provides a new type of monetary-fiscal interaction.
What the paper does
In HANK models, the natural rate depends on the stock of public debt. In the representative agent New Keynesian (RANK) model, the natural rate depends on structural parameters such as productivity growth that are believed to be stable over time. In a class of heterogeneous agent NK (HANK) models, the natural rate additionally depends on the stock of public debt. This is because of market incompleteness in these models: the stock of public debt determines the ability of households to insure against idiosyncratic shocks. This affects the interest rate that clears the market for savings.
Main results
Fiscal policy affects the conduct of monetary policy through the natural rate. Because the natural rate affects the nominal interest rate to be chosen optimally, HANK models necessarily feature monetary-fiscal interaction through this channel. The steady state inflation rate is above the central bank’s target if the natural rate is below the Taylor rule intercept. The central bank can achieve its inflation target by incorporating changes in the natural rate into its interest rate rule. If the debt target is too low such that the natural rate is smaller than minus the inflation rate, the ZLB binds and the central bank is no longer able to achieve its inflation target.
The adjustment in the monetary policy rule to the natural rate weakens the effect of fiscal shocks on nominal and real variables. Figure 1 shows a decomposition of the effect of a sudden debt target increase (by 10pp of initial GDP) on inflation (left panel) and consumption (right panel). The dark grey area indicates the contribution of changes in the expenditure target (G), the light gray area the contribution from changes in the debt target (B), and the red area from changes to the Taylor rule intercept (r). Overall, the debt expansion increases inflation and reduces consumption strongly. Private consumption falls at the expense of an increase in government consumption. The expenditure target falls to maintain fiscal balance, which weakens the inflationary impact. By adjusting for the natural rate increase, the central bank sets a higher interest rate that reduces inflation. The weaker increase in inflation reduces the devaluation of public debt, which limits the public expansion and hence weakens the reduction in private consumption.
Figure 1. Decomposition of the effects of a debt expansion in the model of Campos et al. (2024).
A critique of the paper
The paper demonstrates a novel type of monetary-fiscal interaction. The model could help to rationalize unstable natural rate estimates through volatile fiscal policy. The fact that this finding holds in a quite general class of HANK models, which are increasingly emerging as a useful alternative to RANK models in central banks’ toolkit, makes it appealing.
The inflation implications of a natural rate adjustment are not of first order importance. While the estimated effects are not negligible, it is unclear to which extent they can be confirmed to be significant using empirical approaches. The model decomposition clearly suggests that other channels explain the majority of volatility in real and nominal variables. The standard mechanism of the Fiscal Theory of the Price Level (FTPL), which suggests that an increase in debt levels unfunded by future surpluses forces the central bank to tolerate inflation, appears to be the more important type of monetary-fiscal interaction in practical applications.
Policy implications
Fiscal policy is key. While the FTPL suggests that high (unfunded) debt levels are problematic and can lead to an increase in inflation, the findings from this paper suggest that low debt levels can similarly be problematic and increase the probability of entering the ZLB. As secular forces such as a slowdown in global productivity growth and ageing populations continue to put downward pressure on real interest rates, low debt targets could be an additional structural force limiting central banks’ ability to stimulate the economy. Put it differently: running a correct fiscal policy is key to avoid going back to the ZLB but also to control inflation. The central bank tools alone do have limits. Everyone likes criticizing central banks but the truth is they do what they can, given fiscal policy.
Paper #2: Clancy et al. (2024)
A recent paper titled The Macroeconomic Effects of Global Supply Chain Reorientation by Daragh Clancy (Bank of Ireland), Donal Smith (OECD), and Vilém Valenta (ECB) studies the implications of production reshoring in a DSGE model and finds that the model suggests enforced reduction in import quantity increases inflation along the transition to a new equilibrium and has possible positive effects on long-run output.
What the paper does
The paper studies non-tariff measures that force producers to substitute away from foreign and towards domestic inputs. The authors study the effects of reshoring in a DSGE model of the global economy, simplified to three blocks: the euro area, the United States, and the rest of the world. Export goods can be produced with domestic or foreign inputs. A reshoring shock permanently increases the share of domestic inputs in the production of a region’s export good.
Main results
The effects of reshoring depend on the assumptions for local productivity changes and retaliatory measures. If the euro area reduces the value of imported inputs in the production of export goods by 1% of its GDP, long-run output will increase by 0.5%. This occurs because of equilibrium effects: weaker EA demand for foreign inputs leads foreign exporters to reduce their prices, reducing the marginal cost for EA exporters. This allows EA exporters to reduce their prices and increase their competitiveness. In this scenario, domestic productivity remains unchanged, and the trade partners do not impose reshoring themselves.
If domestic productivity in the tradable goods sector decreases by 0.5% following the reshoring, euro area output falls instead. The productivity decrease could occur because a reduction in trade openness reduces cross-border technology transfers or because local producers face less competition after the regulatory changes. In the model, the negative output effects of weaker productivity occur mostly due to higher marginal costs.
If the trade partners retaliate by reducing their shares of euro area imports equivalently, the output effects are very similar to the baseline scenario. The reason for the slightly positive effects on euro area output is a reduction in inefficiencies: producers have market power and add markups along each step of the value chain. Reshoring reduces the number of steps in production and hence reduces average markups, which leads to welfare gains. Figure 2 compares the effects on output and other variables in the baseline scenario (solid black lines) and the retaliation scenario (dashed lines).
Figure 2. Main result of Clancy et al. (2024). The horizontal axis shows quarters after the shock.
A critique of the paper
The paper addresses an important question and chooses the right tool to do so. Global trade is highly complex, and any shock should be studied in a framework that allows for realistic equilibrium effects. A DSGE model is the established tool for this task. The model also allows an analysis of the transition path, which matters for welfare: Reshoring takes over 10 years to have its full effect and the impact on output suggests that these effects can switch sign over the transition. While output may increase in the long run, its short-term decrease obtains a higher weight in today’s welfare function and matters from a perspective of political feasibility.
There are alternative forms of supply chain resilience that could be studied. The paper’s focus on import restrictions for export goods should not distract from the importance of import restrictions on goods used for domestic production. Similarly, countries could establish supply chain resilience by building up redundancies in the supply chain, diversifying the portfolio of import sources, or importing from more reliable but less efficient partners.
The model estimates are likely to underestimate the negative impacts of reshoring. As the scenario of a simultaneous reshoring and productivity shock shows, the assumptions for domestic productivity can matter strongly for the estimated output effects. A reduction in global trade is likely to coincide with a reduction in the rate of technological exchange, especially for critical and frontier technologies. A model with endogenous productivity would therefore indicate stronger output losses. Similarly, the euro area may not be able to substitute away from certain inputs. Especially foundational inputs that are crucial for production but hard to produce domestically (such as computer chips) affect production strongly. A careful estimation of the model on granular input-level data could yield significantly stronger negative effects from reshoring.
Policy implications
Reshoring need not lead to strong output losses, but the devil lies in the detail. As the model estimates show, the euro area may be able to reduce input shares in the production of certain goods and even achieve welfare gains. This is especially the case for those inputs that can easily be produced domestically while foreign exporters charge high markups for them. However, a range of inputs cannot easily be produced in the euro area, especially in the short run. This is particularly true for high-tech inputs that require domain-specific know-how and large up-front capital investment. A blanket approach to reshoring is therefore unlikely to be successful.