Japan May 2023 CPI Distributions and Models Update

Pressures Still Building Up

Figure 1. Estimated MoM (saar) of core inflation measures.

Note: the figure shows the MoM seasonally adjusted at annual rate of three measures of “core” inflation for the Japanese CPI. The level of the series is seasonally adjusted in-house using X-13 (SEATS option).

The YoY of core-core measures is expected to tick up again in the coming months. The metrics for headline CPI as well as for 3 measures of core inflation are shown in Figure 2. The May report has brought the 3m/3m saar of the index ex fresh food and energy to 5.1%, and the one of the index ex food and energy to 3.2% (bottom panels of Figure 2). In both cases, prices at the margin are still running well above the YoY, suggesting that the latter has room to tick up again in the coming months.

(A technical note: we use the figures below as a guide for future YoY figures. The reader should remember that the 3m/3m (and 6m/6m) lines are subject to revisions because we seasonally adjust the series in-house. In the last 2 reports, the 3m/3m of tthe two core-core measures revised down a bit. In any case, combining this information with the upcoming base-effects, there should be room for the YoY to tick higher next month, then maybe a pause in July, and then again a tick higher in August.)

Figure 2. Metrics of Japanese CPI indexes.

Headline CPI

Index ex fresh food (BoJ)

Index ex fresh food and energy

Index ex food and energy (US-style core)

Evidence from the distribution

Distribution is more dispersed. In May, the unweighted cross-section distribution of MoM (saar) changes across CPI items increased the dispersion, as shown in Figure 3. The upper percentiles moved up, while the bottom percentiles moved down roughly in line with their pre-Covid levels. The movement of the percentiles squares well with the narrative of some deflation in non-durable goods items and renewed inflationary pressures in durable goods and services items.

Figure 3. Cross-section distribution of MoM (%, ar) of CPI items ex food and energy

Note: the Figure shows the median (black thick line) and the percentiles of the cross-sectional distribution of MoM saar items. The distribution excludes food and energy items. The levels of the series (about 300 in total) are seasonally-adjusted in-house using X-13 (SEATS) option. The percentiles shown are the 5th, 10th, 25th, 75th, 90th, and 95th.

Our proxies of the BoJ measures of underlying inflation

We expect the BoJ underlying inflation measures to tick up. Figure 4 shows the three measures of “underlying inflation” published by the BoJ (the blue lines). For each measure, we have calculated a proxy (the yellow lines) starting from the distribution of price changes (on-going research on this point). The takeaway from Figure 4 is that there is room for the three measures to tick up in the next release. Specifically, we expect the weighted median to tick up from 1.2% to 1.4% in the next release. Similar movements are expected for the trimmed mean and the mode.

Figure 4. BoJ measures of underlying inflation and our proxies (%).

BoJ trimmed mean and our proxy

BoJ weighted median and our proxy

BoJ mode and our proxy

Note: the figure shows the measures of “underlying inflation” of the BoJ and our proxies. All figures are YoY changes, in percentage points.

Medium-term forecast

The medium-term forecast points to upside risks. Figure 5 shows our model-based forecast for the three measures of core inflation using the model by BoJ Hogen, Kawamoto and Nakahama (BoJ review, 20215). The evidence in Figure 5 is the result of revised assumptions for the output gap (a bit wider), oil prices, and import prices (a bit lower), as well as today’s incoming data. Overall, the revised assumptions / incoming data resulted in a slightly higher forecast throughout the medium-term (although the revisions are in the order of magnitude of a few tenths). Importantly, the models continue to signal upside risks around the latest BoJ projections. 

(Note: For the record, we have also produced forecasts based on our “main” Phillips curve model adapted to the Japanese case. The results are similar. We do have medium-term model-based forecasts for headline CPI if of any interest. We also have sectoral results adding wage dynamics, if of any interest)

Figure 5. Medium-term model-based forecasts.

Index ex fresh food (BoJ)

Index ex fresh food and energy

Index ex food and energy (US-style core)

Note: The figure shows the model-based forecast of headline CPI and three measures of core CPI. The model is based on Hogen, Kawamoto and Nakahama (BoJ review, 2015). All figures are YoY percent changes. The yellow shadows are intervals of confidence calculated as quasi-out-of sample exercises.

Implications for the BoJ

BoJ to hold… for now. Last month we wrote “The BoJ can hold for a while.. but it should realize pretty soon that its forecast is, once again, too low”. Today’s data are a confirmation that inflationary pressures remain high and above what is implied by the BoJ forecast. If the BoJ staff is using the model by Hogen, Kawamoto and Nakahama (2015) to forecast inflation, it might rely on the fact that the forecasts converge around 2% at the end of the medium-term. Having said that, the experience of the US/EA/UK/Canada/Norway/etc.. should be taken as a warning. The BoJ can hold for now but if the data continue like today, the future is like flipping a coin.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.