Normalization, After All
Core CPI came in as expected post-Tokyo CPI, but below our forecast pre-Tokyo CPI. The distributions show no significant movements in recent months. The medium-term model-based forecasts are a bit lower but remain above the BoJ forecast. In a nutshell: the big picture is largely unchanged. The message of this update is similar to the last few months. As in previous updates, we split the message between (i) the near-term (the next 3 months or so) and (ii) the medium-term forecast. When looking at (i), the distributions suggest no changes, that is a persistent process centered around target. A realistic forecast (MoM saar) for the next few months continues to be around 2 percent for both core-core and core western style. On the other hand, when looking at (ii), which is more relevant for monetary policy, the medium-term models remain a bit above the BoJ forecast and above target. Therefore, we continue to expect the BoJ to normalize rates to neutral.
A PDF containing all relevant CPI charts can be downloaded here.
A PDF containing all relevant labor market charts can be downloaded here.
MoM (saar) on the weak side. We estimate that in April the index ex fresh food (BoJ) was flat (Figure 1). As for the other two measures of core inflation, we estimate that the index ex fresh food and energy (core core) was also flat. Finally, the index ex food and energy (US-style core) increased 1.1% MoM saar. Today’s prints are in line with the post-Tokyo CPI expectations but below the pre-Tokyo CPI forecast. Today’s print appears to be influenced by a one-off factor. Looking at the distributions, we continue to see near-term prints around target (see next section). The NSA indexes (see here of core western-style) also suggest that the YoY should be around target by the end of the year.
Figure 1. Estimated MoM (saar) of core inflation measures.
Note: the figure shows the MoM seasonally adjusted at annual rate of three measures of “core” inflation for the Japanese CPI.
The metrics suggest some cooling. The metrics for headline CPI as well as for 3 measures of core inflation are shown in Figure 2. Today’s report has brought the 3m/3m saar of core-core to 1.5%, and western-style core to 1.5% (bottom panels of Figure 2). In both cases, prices at the margin are running lower than the YoY, suggesting that the latter has room to tick down in the coming months. Having said that, we expect the sequential readings to stabilize around target going forward (see below).
Figure 2. Metrics of Japanese CPI indexes.
Headline CPI
Index ex fresh food (BoJ)
Index ex fresh food and energy (core-core)
Index ex food and energy (western-style core)
Evidence from the distribution
Distribution centered around target, no sign of movements. This month, the distribution moved to the left (ridge plot here). We do not take signal from today’s moves, as the distribution (of western-style core) shows no movements when extending the horizon (see Figure 3). The distribution continues to be centered around target, and suggests moderate sequential readings in the near-term (i.e. MoM saar around 2%).
Figure 3. Distribution of CPI items ex food and energy (MoM saar, %).
Our proxies of the BoJ measures of underlying inflation
BoJ underlying inflation measures (YoY) can tick down. Figure 4 shows the three measures of “underlying inflation” published by the BoJ (the blue lines). For each measure, we calculated a proxy (the yellow lines) starting from the distribution of price changes. The takeaway from Figure 4 is that our proxies remain above the BoJ measures but they are moving down. The MoM series (here the BoJ mode and our MoM ar proxy) are also moving down now. For this reason, we expect the BoJ measures to tick down in the coming months.
Figure 4. BoJ measures of underlying inflation and our proxies (%).
BoJ trimmed mean and our proxy
BoJ weighted median and our proxy
BoJ mode and our proxy
Note: the figure shows the measures of “underlying inflation” of the BoJ and our proxies. All figures are YoY changes, in percentage points.
Medium-term forecast
The medium-term forecasts continue to point to some upside risks around the BoJ projections. Figure 5 shows our model-based forecast for the three measures of core inflation using the model by BoJ Hogen, Kawamoto and Nakahama (BoJ review, 20215). This is the first time we include Q2 in sample. The Q2 nowcast is a bit lower than the model own forecast for the current quarter. For this reason, the models have revised down a bit the forecast (see Table 1). Nevertheless, the overall message is intact: the medium-term model-based forecast remains above (or well above) the last BoJ forecast (and the 2% target) at almost every horizon.
An Excel file containing all data of Figure 5 can be downloaded here.
Figure 5. Medium-term model-based forecasts.
Index ex fresh food (BoJ)
Index ex fresh food and energy (core-core)
Index ex food and energy (western-style core)
Table 1. Summary of model-based forecasts
Note: The figure shows the model-based forecast of headline CPI and three measures of core CPI. The model is based on Hogen, Kawamoto and Nakahama (BoJ review, 2015). All figures are YoY percent changes. The yellow shadows are intervals of confidence calculated as quasi-out-of sample exercises. The summary table shows the average of the YoY model-based in each fiscal year (Q2, Q3, Q4, and Q1 of the following calendar year).
“Acquired inflation” and “carryover effect”
Carryover for 2024 suggests some upside risks around the BoJ forecast. Figure 6 shows a comparison between our (model-based) forecast for BoJ core and core-core vs the BoJ latest forecast and the estimated “acquired inflation” and “carry-over” effects. The main takeaway is that the model-based forecast remains above the BoJ forecast. Conditional on our forecast, the carryover for FY2024 is around 1%, which means that the BoJ forecast for FY2024 is probably a bit too low. The risks around the BoJ staff forecast are to the upside, including at the end of the medium-term forecast. In our estimates, the most likely scenario is that the BoJ staff will revise up (marginally) again its forecast for core-core.
Figure 6. Underlying Inflation forecast vs BoJ forecast vs “acquired inflation”
Implications for the BoJ
Rates to neutral. After today’s report, the big picture remains largely unchanged, as the data remain broadly consistent with target. The BoJ has hiked. The next steps should be to bring rates to neutral.