Is the American Rescue Plan Taking Us Back to the ’60s?

The SF Fed has published an analysis titled “Is the American Rescue Plan Taking Us Back to the ’60s?“.

Research question

The goal of the analysis is to estimate the impact of the American Rescue Plan (ARP) passed last March on core (PCE) inflation. The timing  of ARP (approved while the economy was already experiencing a strong rebound) raised concerns about the risk of fueling inflation.

Methodology

The authors (Regis Barnichon, Luiz E. Oliveira, and Adam H. Shapiro) employ Phillips curve methods to estimate the slope of the Phillips curve and therefore the possible impact of the ARP on core inflation. The novelty is that the authors have chosen a non-traditional measure of “slack”: the vacancy-to-unemployment ratio. The authors claim that this ratio captures the level of labor demand relative to the level of labor supply. As such, it should better capture “slack” than the unemployment or vacancy rate alone: an increase in the vacancy-to-unemployment ratio can be interpreted according to the authors as a higher demand for labor relative to supply, that is, less labor market slack.

Results

The authors show that the ARP is expected to push the vacancy-to-unemployment ratio up by approximately 0.6 units over 2021, and less than 0.5 units by the end of 2022. This effect is large, given that labor market tightness currently stands at about 1.25 units. The authors also show that the increase in labor market tightness, attributable to the ARP, is expected to cause inflation to increase by about 0.3 percentage point in 2021 and by a bit more than 0.2 percentage point in 2022. The impact in 2023 is negligible. Thus, the estimated impact of the ARP on inflation is meaningful, but it is still a far cry from the strong overheating of the 1960s.

The key point to understand the authors’ results is that  the evolution of the impact on inflation from the ARP depends on two factors. First, the ARP’s impact on labor market tightness is temporary, as it peaks in 2021 but falls thereafter (see Figure here below). Second, although there is some risk that the recent high inflation episode could make businesses expect higher future inflation and thereby cause longer-run inflation expectations to rise, the authors assume that expectations for longer-run inflation remain strongly anchored as they have been over the past 20 years.

Implications for the Fed Board staff

The Board staff will review the SF Fed analysis carefully. Overall, the results are a large confirmation of the main staff thesis that currently high readings of core PCE price inflation should prove largely transitory and that the Phillips curve remains pretty flat, no matter what measure of slack is used.

Figures

Figure 1 Estimated impact of ARP on vacancy-to-unemployment ratio

Note: impact on vacancy-to-unemployment ratio is measured in job vacancies per unemployed person; impact on core PCE inflation is measured in percentage point. Figure from the original paper.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.