Inflation Narratives – A Review

To keep in mind

The responses from ad-hoc surveys of a representative sample of the US population as well as academic economists and US firm managers show that households and managers are more likely than experts to think that the current surge in inflation will be persistent. As such, households and managers inflation expectations appear to be less likely to remain anchored if communication from policy makers will not be adequately targeted. Nevertheless, it remains unclear the optimal communication strategy to implement in such environment.

What the paper does

The authors analyze ad-hoc surveys conducted in November 2021 with a broadly representative sample of the US population as well as with samples of academic economists and US firm managers. To analyze the open-ended responses in a structured way, the authors hand-code each response according to a coding scheme that includes the most prominent theoretical explanations for the surge in inflation as well as a series of explanations that are not typically captured in economic theories, but which are commonly mentioned by households. The motivation is that the narrative behind the surge in inflation might have important implications for how persistent each agent expect inflation to be. For instance, if households associate the surge in inflation with temporary factors, such as pent-up demand after the end of lockdowns, de-anchoring of long-term inflation expectations seems less likely than if they associate it with more structural changes in the labor market or a shift in central bank priorities towards looser policies.

Results

The authors show that households and managers are more likely than experts to think that the current surge in inflation will be persistent. In details:

  • Households tend to put less emphasis on demand-side explanation and are relatively more likely to emphasize supply chain issues and generic narratives related to the pandemic or political issues. The three most cited explanations by households are labor shortages (26%), supply chain issues (25%), and politics (24%).

 

  • Experts’ responses focus on a combination of supply- and demand-side mechanisms and are usually quite rich and complex in nature. The three most common explanations cited by experts relate to supply chain issues (55%), government spending (46%), and monetary policy (37%). Experts thus tend to focus on textbook explanations related to higher production costs or aggregate fiscal and monetary stimuli.

 

  • Managers tend to provide stories more similar to households than academic experts and are most likely to emphasize labor shortages (22%), supply chain issues (22%), and generic references to corona (19%) to explain the rise in inflation.

 

The authors also show (see Figure 2 of the paper – reported here below) that households and managers are more likely than experts to think that the current surge in inflation will be persistent. Experts predict an inflation rate of 3.7% over the next 12 months, compared to 4.1% among managers and 4.7% among households. For the five-year-ahead forecast, experts predict an inflation rate of 2.6%, while managers and households expect inflation rates of 3.4% and 3.9%, respectively. 

Comment and implications for the Fed

In our view, this is a very interesting analysis that fills some of the (several) gaps in the literature on inflation expectations. As discussed in private meetings (see our set of slides “103. inflation expectations – the elephant in the room.pptx”), inflation expectations are crucial for monetary policy but still little understood. For instance, it is unclear what expectations (households vs. markets vs. firms vs. experts) matter for actual inflation and why.

Also, as pointed out by Carola Binder’s research, it is unclear what the monetary authority could or should do in terms of communication to re-anchor long-term expectations (from Binder (2021): “Most people don’t want to pay attention to central bank communication. […] When Fed officials do manage to get the attention of the general public, the reaction is usually highly politicized. […] But to use inflation expectations “as a policy tool,” being newsworthy is a must. This is a big problem. It is not feasible, and if it were feasible, it wouldn’t necessarily be desirable.”).

The Vow EU article shows that both households and managers perceive the surge in inflation as persistent (and even the experts 5-year inflation forecast are a bit above the Fed target). Put it differently, the authors’ results show that the risks of de-anchoring are probably higher than measured by traditional surveys monitored at the Fed (i.e. Michigan survey). However, it remains unclear what strategy the Fed should put in place rather than trying to control actual inflation and ensure it moderates fast enough going forward.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.