Autopilot. The October Governing Council meeting is, in our view, “on autopilot”. The incoming data have been weaker than we expected but they support the 2023 ECB/NCBs staff forecast in the latest macroeconomic projection exercise. We continue to see an issue with the 2024 forecast of the ECB/NCBs staff (as well as the models continue to be above target at the end of the medium-term) but this is a discussion for the December round. For now, the Taylor rules continue to imply a “for longer” message, suggesting that the deposit rate might remain around 4% for long. We expect Lagarde to deliver this message.
Main points:
Some promising signs in incoming data. In 2023, core HICP prices have followed closely the (NSA) path observed in 2022, as the weakness in core goods has offset the strength in core services. In September, the series has (finally) deviated, although the new trend needs to be confirmed.
Figure 1. Evolution of cumulative (unchained) core HICP by year.
The main model forecast is revised down. The “main” model forecast (sample ends in Q3) is a bit weaker than at the time of the September GC meeting as a result of weaker than expected incoming data and a higher path of the unemployment rate. The model forecast using the unemployment rate as a measure of “slack” is: 5.2% (average YoY) in 2023, 3.7% in 2024, 3.1% in 2025, and 3.1% in 2026. In any case, the forecast remains well above the ECB target at the end of the medium-term.
Figure 2. Current vs previous GC round “main” model medium-term forecast.
The Taylor rules continue to imply a “for longer” message. The inertial Taylor rules conditional on (i) the degree of inertia consistent with observed path of the ECB deposit rate, and (ii) on a forecast for core inflation and the unemployment rate as in the macroeconomic projection exercise, suggests that the deposit rate might remain around 4% for long.
Figure 3. Taylor rules