Taking time. The outcome of the April Governing Council meeting was in line with our expectations. In our view, both the Governing Council and President Lagarde have essentially taken time. The press release and the Q&A session made it clear that the Governing Council must consider a wide range of scenarios.
While it is true that our current projections for headline inflation are above the March ECB baseline scenario, it is equally true that we remain closer to the baseline than to the alternative scenarios. More importantly, we believe the ECB is fully aware that these scenarios can change—and can do so very rapidly. At present, the key variable appears to be the timing and resolution of the conflict.
If the conflict in Iran were to be resolved relatively quickly, we continue to believe that the ECB would have little inclination to raise interest rates. It would be forced to act only if the conflict were to persist and energy prices were to remain elevated for a prolonged period. This is also because there are still no signs of second-round effects in the system, a situation which is likely to persist into June, as such dynamics typically take time to materialize. Short-term inflation expectations have reacted negatively to recent data, while long-term expectations remain well anchored, as noted in the press release. Here again, much will depend on developments in gasoline prices, and therefore on the evolution of the Middle East conflict.
Overall, our conclusion is that, at its core, the Governing Council is attempting to resist the need to raise interest rates. This is also supported by some recent labor market data—for instance, this morning’s Italian employment figures—which appear somewhat weak. If pushed into a corner, the ECB may ultimately act in June, but only under such circumstances, in our view.
The press release
Taking time. In our view, the key point of the press release is the following: “The war in the Middle East has led to a sharp increase in energy prices, pushing up inflation and weighing on economic sentiment. The implications of the war for medium-term inflation and economic activity will depend on the intensity and duration of the energy price shock and the scale of its indirect and second-round effects. The longer the war continues and the longer energy prices remain high, the stronger is the likely impact on broader inflation and the economy. The Governing Council remains well positioned to navigate the current uncertainty. The euro area entered this period of surging energy prices with inflation at around the 2% target, and the economy has shown resilience over recent quarters. Longer-term inflation expectations remain well anchored, although inflation expectations over shorter horizons have moved up significantly.”
Our comment: the stress is on the intensity and the duration of the conflict.
Q&A
Question. Where is the ECB? In which scenario (baseline, adverse, severe) are we in?
Lagarde: “I think we would all wish that there was a quick end to the war. But looking at our monetary policy and the decision that we made today, we decided to keep the three interest rates unchanged.
And to address your new question, I’m not going to tell you whether we are closer to the baseline scenario or to scenario two, because I think that what we have debated over the course of yesterday and today with the Governing Council is where we are relative to the baseline. And the conclusion is that we are certainly moving away from the baseline.
Where exactly we are, at what point between the baseline and other scenarios, is not the most relevant assessment. We are moving away from the baseline, and what is critically important is the impact that energy prices will have.
I said last time in March that it would be a question of the duration, the depth, and the propagation. And this is clearly what we need to better assess.
If I were to summarize what we decided today, I would say that we made an informed decision on the basis of yet insufficient information.
Why do I say it’s an informed decision? Because we debated at length and in-depth various options. We debated the decision that we have unanimously taken today, but we also debated at length and in depth a decision to possibly hike.
So that was debated amongst all governors, and I’m sure that you will meet some governors who will argue both sides—or maybe one side—of both proposals.
So, it was really a deeply discussed monetary policy stance, of which the outcome was a unanimous decision to leave the three interest rates unchanged.
And I’m saying that it’s an informed decision based on insufficient information because, while the hard data is broadly in line with our projections and what we discussed back in March, there is such uncertainty that we need to understand and revisit all of that at our next monetary policy meeting.
We believe that, given the position we are in—and we say in the monetary policy statement that we started from a good position, we were well positioned to navigate—these six weeks will be the right time to assess developments, to understand in particular the outcome of the conflict, or, if there is no outcome, that in and of itself will be informative.
This will allow us to make an informed decision based on verified and revisited information that we will receive in the next few months.
That is the clearest way, I hope it was clear, that I can describe the really good discussions that we had both yesterday and today.”
Our comment: Lots of words! Our summary: the ECB knows that things can change, and very quickly. Indeed, the headline forecast is above the March baseline (but way below the adverse scenario). To us, anything can happen until June, way too early to call a hike.
Question. When can we see second-round effects? June or later? Is there any scenario in which the ECB does not react to higher energy prices?
Lagarde: “First of all, the ECB will always react, because we will take inflation back to 2%. So whatever the situation, we will react.
On timing and propagation: we believe that by June, we will have a lot more information that will help us revisit, ascertain, and verify whether or not we are seeing second-round effects.
As I said, the number of indicators will include many elements—from wage setting, hiring, selling price revisions, to commodity prices. I should have mentioned that one first: commodity prices, because it’s both oil and gas, but also all the derivatives and everything that is actually channeled through the Strait of Hormuz in particular.
We will take all that into account, and we will do so continuously.”
Our comment: They need to talk hawkish, of course. But acting remains to be seen, especially because in our view, there will be little sign of second-round effect by June (if any, it will take way longer).