December 2022 FOMC: “Until Inflation is Coming Down”

Until Inflation is Coming Down in a Sustained Way

The December FOMC was unsurprising from our point of view. Despite the good news from the incoming data, the medium-term outllook for inflation is still unfavorable. Therefore, the FOMC cannot pivot and continues signal high rates “until we are really confident that inflation is coming down in a sustained way” (Powell).

Put it differently, what we have called “the tension” (that is, the disconnection between the signals from the near-term data and the medium-term model-based forecast for core inflation) will continue until the models will deliver a much lower forecast.

The only relevant question is the following: when will the medium-term models “pivot”? (that is, when will they signal -and what will it take for them to signal- that inflation is on its way back to 2% with high probability?)

The FOMC will pivot when the Fed staff will pivot. And the Fed staff will pivot when the Fed models will pivot. Chances are we are not too far away anymore (March FOMC first chance, June with high probability).

Statement

The statement was essentially identical compared to the November FOMC.

SEP projections

The new SEP came in as expected and discussed in private meetings. The FOMC expects the FF rate to be above 5% in 2023 and above 4% in 2024 (we signalled the risk in 2024 compared to markets’ expectations in private meetings). We are not surprised because this is in line with what the Fed staff (2021) Taylor rule suggested under the new forecasts for core PCE price inflation and the unemployment rate (slide from our Pre-December 2022 FOMC meeting package below, data for simulations available upon request, as usual).

The new SEP forecast for core PCE price inflation is still below our estimated “main” model but the gap is slowly closing. The rise of the unemployment rate in the SEP projection continues to be “gentle”. In other words, the SEP continues its “immaculate disinflation”. We continue to disagree but the chances of a soft landing have risen a bit recently.

Remarks

Powell: “Inflation data received so far for October and November show a welcome reduction in the monthly pace of price increases. But it will take substantially more evidence to have confidence that inflation is on a sustained downward path“.

Comment: Translated: there is a difference between the near-term and the medium-term outlook. Markets tend to react to the latest data but what sets monetary policy is the medium-term forecast. When Powell says “substantially more evidence” he means that the FOMC needs to have evidence that inflation is returning to 2% in the medium-term. The models are not there yet, despite the good news in the near-term outlook.

Q&As

Q1 Are financial conditions appropriate?

Powell answered this question by saying that the FOMC continues to think that monetary policy is not restrictive enough. For this reason, the FF rate is projected to rise going forward. Continuing in his answer, Powell said that financial conditions need to remain restrictive “until we’re really confident that inflation is coming down in a sustained way”.

Finally, Powell described the recent evolution of CPI inflation data and he entered into the details of the main items: core goods, core services excluding shelter, and housing services. Skipping the details for brevity, Powell stressed what research has shown: core goods inflation is volatile, and core services is very persistent. Finally, Powell mentioned that the expected persistency of inflation is the reason why the committee expects rates to remain higher for quite some time.

Comment: The key point in Powell’s word is the sentence “until we’re really confident that inflation is coming down in a sustained way”. Translated: the Fed cannot pivot until their medium-term models will not give them green light. Until then, we will continue with what we have described as a “tension”: the incoming data might continue to be soft but if the medium-term outlook remains unfavorable the Fed will not pivot. The natural question is then: when will the models turn? The answer is pretty long (a note is coming next week) but the short answer is “at the end of 2023:Q1 there is a discrete chance and a high chance in Q2”.

Q2 How should we interpret the higher core PCE price inflation forecast in the SEP? Should the FF rate be higher than 5.1%?

Powell:  “We are going into next year with higher inflation than we thought”.  […] “What you see is our best estimate as of today for how high we need to raise rates to… how much we need to tighten policy to create enough… you know… restrictive policy to slow economic activity […] and bring inflation down through those channels. That is the best estimate we make today.”

Comment: There seemed to be some confusion among journalists and Fed watchers about the SEP forecast (higher core PCE price inflation and higher FF rate). From our perspective it is hard to understand the surprise. Compared to the September SEP (and not the latest CPI report), the inflation data have come in a bit stronger than expected (by the committee, the Fed staff, and the models), so the path of the FF rate must be higher via the Taylor rule. The FOMC could have put out an even higher path of the FF rate and a lower forecast for core inflation but their own reaction function suggested it was not optimal because it would have pushed the unemployment rate higher. So it is better to accept a higher inflation rate, in order to save the labor market.

Q3 Cutting rates next year? Under what conditions?

Powell:  “I wouldn’t see us considering [cuts] until the committee is confident that inflation is moving towards 2% in a sustained way.”

Comment: Powell gave the only possible answer. But he knows that things can change (and he admitted that the path of the FF rate can be lower should we get downward surprises going forward). So again the question is: when will the medium-term models pivot? What needs to happen in the incoming data for the models to pivot? Again, the answer is long, and we will cover the details next week but as mentioned at this point another 2-3 soft CPI reports can make the Fed pivot. This implies that a pivot is potentially on the table as soon as March (June being very likely if the data cooperate).

Q4 Are you more confident now after the November CPI report?

Powell: “[The November CPI report] provides greater confidence in our forecast of declining inflation. As I mentioned we’ve been expecting significant declines in overall inflation. And this is the kind of reading that it will take to support that. So really this gives us greater confidence in our forecast”.

Comment: After the CPI report we commented that in the last 3 months the Fed staff near-term forecast  has (finally!) been pretty accurate. The Fed staff is back in business, and Powell seems more confident in the forecast now. This is excellent news: if Powell is more confident in the Fed staff forecast, we expect him and the FOMC to pivot when the staff will pivot.

About wages

Powell: “If you look at wages, look at the average hourly earnings number we got with the last payrolls report. You don’t really see much progress in terms of average hourly earnings coming down. There may be composition effects and other effects in that so we don’t put too much weight on any one report. These things can be volatile month to month. But we’ll be looking for wages moving,you know, down to more normal levels where workers are doing well and ultimately their gains are not being eaten up by inflation”.

Comment: What Powell said is broadly consistent with the note we circulated on AHE. We continue to suspect Powell has in mind the message the Fed staff has delivered, something along these lines: “we don’t really believe in the November data because of the distortions of the denominator and the survey response rate. Probably the “true” pace is lower and wages continue to go sideways at an average of 5%-ish, about 2% higher than the level consistent with the Fed target”.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.