Local (global?) maximum of hawkishness
An update on the latest FOMC participants’ statements on inflation and possible path for monetary policy.
We have heard from: Brainard, Bullard, Collins, George, Mester, Barkin, Bostic, Daly, Evans, and Kashkari.
Keep in mind
Most participants this week reiterated the message of the September FOMC. However, some participants stressed that there are risks on both sides (see for instance Fed Collins below). Notably, in a prepared speech Vice Chair Brainard stressed that “it is important to consider how cross-border spillovers and spillbacks might interact with financial vulnerabilities.” Translated: what happens in the UK does not stay in the UK.
The Fed cannot pivot right now. But given what happened last week on the markets, we are probably at a local maximum of hawkishness. Data will suggest whether this is a global maximum. For the time being, in our view, it is hard to bet on a more hawkish Fed.
Jerome H. Powell – Chair – Neutral
No recent statements.
Lael Brainard – Governor – Dovish
September 30
From Fed Board (here). “The global environment of high inflation and rising interest rates highlights the importance of paying attention to financial stability considerations for monetary policy. As monetary policy tightens globally to combat high inflation, it is important to consider how cross-border spillovers and spillbacks might interact with financial vulnerabilities.”
“Tightening in financial conditions similarly spills over to financial conditions elsewhere, which amplifies the tightening effects. These spillovers across jurisdictions are present for decreases in the size of the central bank balance sheet as well as for increases in the policy rate. Some estimates suggest that the spillovers of monetary policy surprises between more tightly linked advanced economies such as the United States and Europe could be about half the size of the own-country effect when measured in terms of relative changes in local currency bond yields.”
“In contrast, spillovers through exchange rate channels tend to go in opposite directions. The Federal Reserve’s broad nominal U.S. dollar index has appreciated over 10 percent year to date. On balance, dollar appreciation tends to reduce import prices in the United States. But in some other jurisdictions, the corresponding currency depreciation may contribute to inflationary pressures and require additional tightening to offset.”
“It will take time for the full effect of tighter financial conditions to work through different sectors and to bring inflation down. Monetary policy will need to be restrictive for some time to have confidence that inflation is moving back to target. For these reasons, we are committed to avoiding pulling back prematurely. We also recognize that risks may become more two sided at some point. Uncertainty is currently high, and there are a range of estimates around the appropriate destination of the target range for the cycle. Proceeding deliberately and in a data-dependent manner will enable us to learn how economic activity and inflation are adjusting to the cumulative tightening and to update our assessments of the level of the policy rate that will need to be maintained for some time to bring inflation back to 2 percent.”
Michael S. Barr – Governor – Neutral
No recent statements.
Christopher J. Waller – Governor – Hawkish
No recent statements.
Michelle W. Bowman – Governor – Neutral
No recent statements.
Lisa D. Cook – Governor – Neutral
No recent statements.
Philip N. Jefferson – Governor – Neutral
No recent statements.
John C. Williams – New York Fed President – Dovish
No recent statements.
Fed Presidents with voting power in 2022
James Bullard – St. Louis Fed President – Hawkish
September 29
From Bloomberg (here). ‘“If you look at the dots, it does look like the committee is expecting a fair amount of additional moves this year,” St. Louis Fed President James Bullard told a virtual emerging-market forum, referring to the bank’s so-called dot plot of projections. “I think that that was digested by markets and does seem to be the right interpretation.”
“We’re determined to get to the right level of the policy rate in order to put meaningful downward pressure on inflation here,” he told reporters via telephone conference call following his speech.
Susan M. Collins – Boston Fed President – Neutral
September 26
From Bloomberg (here). “Returning inflation to target will require further tightening of monetary policy, as signaled in the recent FOMC projections,” Collins said Monday in remarks prepared for an event with the Greater Boston Chamber of Commerce. “It will be important to see clear and convincing signs that inflation is falling.”
“I do anticipate that accomplishing price stability will require slower employment growth and a somewhat higher unemployment rate,” Collins said. “And I take very seriously that unemployment is painful, and that its costs have been disproportionately concentrated among groups that have traditionally been marginalized.”
“I do believe that we can achieve this [soft landing], but I think it’s important to recognize that there are risks on both sides,” Collins said in the question-and-answer portion of the event. She also said she thinks inflation may have peaked or is nearing a peak.”
Esther L. George – Kansas City Fed President – Hawkish
September 9
From Bloomberg (here). “The case for continuing to remove policy accommodation remains clear-cut,” George said Friday in remarks prepared for a virtual event organized by the Peterson Institute for International Economics. “The key questions are by how much and how quickly.”
“We will have to determine the course of our policy through observation rather than reference to theoretical models or pre-pandemic trends,” said George, who did not specify in her remarks the size of the rate increase that she would support later this month. “Given the likely lags in the pass-through of tighter monetary policy to real economic conditions, this argues for steadiness and purposefulness over speed.”
Loretta J. Mester – Cleveland Fed President – Neutral
September 29
From Bloomberg (here). “Real interest rates — judged by the expectations over the next year of inflation — have to be in positive territory and held there for a time,” she said earlier in an interview on CNBC. “We’re still not even in restricted territory on the funds rate.”
Asked in a later panel discussion if a US recession would stay her hand in terms of raising interest rates, Mester said: “We’re going to do what we have to do to get the price stability. So — no.”
Mester said her forecast is probably a bit above the median path because she sees inflation being persistent, based on her conversations with businesses, community development groups and other sources.
“In my SEP I have inflation coming down, but we have to bring interest rates up to get that downward shift in inflation,” she said, adding that the US economy has so far been able to handle the higher interest rates.
Fed Presidents with no voting power in 2022
Thomas I. Barkin – Richmond Fed President – Neutral
September 30
From Bloomberg (here). “Our rate and balance-sheet moves take time to bring inflation down,” he said in remarks prepared for delivery at an event hosted by the Prince William Chamber of Commerce in Virginia Friday. “The Fed will persist until they do.”
“Inflation should come down, but I don’t expect its drop to be immediate nor predictable,” said Barkin, who isn’t a voter on the rate-setting Federal Open Market Committee this year. “Significant shocks simply take time to dampen,” he said, referring to the disruptions created by the Covid-19 pandemic, supply-chain snarls, and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
“The Fed is moving expeditiously,” Barkin said. “We have raised rates 300 basis points, started shrinking our balance sheet aggressively and signaled there are more rate increases to come.”
Raphael Bostic – Atlanta Fed President – Neutral
September 28
From Bloomberg (here). “The lack of progress thus far has me thinking much more now that we have to get to a moderately restrictive stance,” he told reporters Wednesday via a telephone conference call. “And for me, that is in the 4.25% to 4.5% range for our policy. My preference is that we get there by year end.”
Bostic said his forecast is for another 75 basis-point hike at the Fed’s November meeting followed by 50 basis points in December, adding it’s contingent on the incoming data. He also said he would like to stop rate hikes before inflation hits the 2% goal to avoid overtightening.
“I don’t think it’ll be appropriate for us to continue to tighten and increase your rates until inflation gets to 2%,” Bostic said. “That will be guaranteeing that we’ve gone too far and we’ll take the economy into a negative space.”
“I’m still in the place of not really thinking that a recession is a foregone conclusion as we battle this,” he said. “So we can have some weakening, but I don’t think it, at this point, will take us to the historical recessionary experience.”
Mary C. Daly – San Francisco Fed President – Dovish
September 28
From Bloomberg (here). To keep inflation low and stable, “we have to balance that off with our dual mandate with full employment,” Daly said at the Symposium on Asian Banking and Finance. “Trying to navigate that to bring inflation down while we do so as gently as possible, not to tip unnecessarily the economy into a downturn that actually influences the full employment part of our mandate, is a struggle.”
“While there’s hopeful signs, I’m always mindful that we might have to do a little more on demand because supply chains are just sluggish, or supply is sluggish to recover,” Daly said.
“Some of the factors that were pushing inflation down and even keeping the neutral rate of interest so low may be changing,” Daly said. “We might very well come out of this episode with higher inflation and be in a world where we’re trying to balance inflation to the target.”
Charles L. Evans – Chicago Fed President – Dovish
September 28
From Bloomberg (here). “We’re at a target range of 3 to 3.25%,” Evans told reporters Wednesday after a talk at the London School of Economics, referring to the US central bank’s benchmark lending rate.
“That is beginning to move into restrictive territory, but with inflation as high as it is, and getting inflation under control being job one, it’s not nearly restrictive enough,” Evans said.
“The risks continue to be high about more persistent inflation, and we just really need to get inflation in check,” Evans said.
“I am nervous about the fundamentals for the economy. I think that they are still good — I think the labor market is still good — but we need to be mindful of deterioration,” he said. “And we need to have quite a substantial amount of indication of that before you can seriously weigh that against the very high inflation that we’re facing now.”
Patrick T. Harker – Philadelphia Fed President – Hawkish
Harker published an essay on shelter inflation (here). The essay is interesting and discusses ways to reduce shelter inflation but does not have implications for monetary policy.
Neel Kashkari – Minneapolis – Dovish
September 27
From Bloomberg (here). “We are moving very aggressively,” he said Tuesday during a Wall Street Journal event. “There’s a lot of tightening in the pipeline. We are committed to restoring price stability but we also recognize given these lags there is a risk of overdoing it.”
Asked if he saw grounds for an even larger 100 basis-point increase, Kashkari said “the pace that we’re undertaking right now is appropriate.”
“We need to keep tightening policy until we see some compelling evidence that core inflation is actually having peaked and is on its way down,” Kashkari said. “We need to get policy to a stance where we’re clearly tightening the economy and then we need to be patient.”
Lorie K. Logan – Dallas – Neutral
No recent statements.