Recent FOMC Participants Statements Update

FOMC needs much more to pivot

An update on the latest FOMC participants’ statements on inflation and possible path for monetary policy. 

We have heard from: Bowman, Bullard, Barkin, Daly, Evans, and Kashkari.

Keep in mind

All FOMC participants who spoke this week (including after the July CPI report) reiterated that the Fed needs much more before declaring victory. One data point (and possibly a second “soft” reading in August as we expect) is not enough. As for the path of the FF rate, all FOMC participants remain committed to deliver the path of June SEP dots plot.

We are happy to see that no participants made the mistake of last March when some took a “soft” month as a change in trend. The baseline remains the same: the models are telling us that inflation will somehow moderate in the coming months but the Fed has a mandate and, conditional on current monetary policy, the monthly prints might remain above target for several months. For this reason, we continue to think that the FOMC participants are genuine when signalling rates will increase in 2022 and remain elevated in the first half of next year.

FOMC-meter

Dovish

Leal Brainard

John Williams

Charles Evans

Mary C. Daly

Neel Kashkari

Neutral

Jerome H. Powell

Michelle W. Bowman

Philip N. Jefferson

Lisa D. Cook

Thomas I. Barkin

Raphael Bostic

 

Hawkish

Christopher Waller

James Bullard

Esther L. George

Loretta J. Mester

Patrick T. Harker

Jerome H. Powell – Chair – Neutral

No recent statements.

Lael Brainard – Governor – Dovish

No recent statements.

Christopher J. Waller – Governor – Hawkish

No recent statements.

Michelle W. Bowman – Governor – Neutral

August 6 (pre July CPI)

From Fed Board (here).  “I see a significant risk of high inflation into next year for necessities including food, housing, fuel, and vehicles. Rents have grown dramatically, and while home sales have slowed, the continued increasing price of single-family homes indicates to me that rents won’t decline anytime in the near future.”

“The supply problems pushing up inflation seem likely to persist. Indications are that the conflict in Ukraine will continue, and that the effects of shipping disruptions of agriculture products and limits on energy supplies from Russia will continue to be a significant problem.”

“Based on current economic conditions and the outlook I just described, I supported the FOMC’s decision last week to raise the federal funds rate another 75 basis points. I also support the Committee’s view that “ongoing increases” would be appropriate at coming meetings. My view is that similarly-sized increases should be on the table until we see inflation declining in a consistent, meaningful, and lasting way.”

Lisa D. Cook – Governor – Neutral

No recent statements.

Philip N. Jefferson – Governor – Neutral

No recent statements.

John C. Williams – New York Fed President – Dovish

No recent statements.

Fed Presidents with voting power in 2022

James Bullard – St. Louis Fed President – Hawkish

August 9 (pre July CPI)

From St Louis Fed (here) and MarketNews (here). “Bullard reiterated his belief that the Fed’s policy rate will reach 3.75% to 4% by the end of the year, adding that this level is a bit higher than he would have thought even a couple of months ago because “inflation has continued to broaden out and doesn’t look like it’s turning the corner, at least based on the evidence we have today.”

And if inflation continues to surprise to the upside, “we’ll have to be higher for longer and the market will have to price that in,” he said.

Bullard said he thought that compelling evidence of lowering inflation would be seeing year-over-year inflation measures coming down months in a row and possibly supported by anecdotal evidence that firms felt their pricing powers were being reduced, such as firms being worried about losing market share if they increase prices.

That would indicate a disinflationary dynamic that the U.S. experienced in the 1980s, Bullard pointed out. “And I think that’s the process through which we can get back to 2% in a relatively short period of time, like 18 months,” he said.

Esther L. George – Kansas City Fed President – Hawkish

No recent statements.

Loretta J. Mester – Cleveland Fed President – Neutral

No recent statements.

Fed Presidents with no voting power in 2022

Thomas I. Barkin – Richmond Fed President – Neutral

August 12

From Bloomberg (here). “I’d like to see a period of sustained inflation under control,” Barkin said in an interview on CNBC Friday. “Until we do that, I think we are going to just have to continue to move rates into restrictive territory.”

“I want to see real rates across the curve sustained in positive territory,” he said. “I think we are on the brink of moving real rates into positive territory across the curve. We need to sustain it there. And we need to follow through on some of the expectations that are out there in terms of the rate path in order to keep it there.”

“What you try to do is try to get inflation down on a sustained basis, and then you have the freedom to loosen,” Barkin said. “If you can get to our target for a number of months, that’s what we would like to see.”

Raphael Bostic – Atlanta Fed President – Neutral

No recent statements.

Mary C. Daly – San Francisco Fed President – Dovish

August 11

From FT (here).  “There’s good news on the month-to-month data that consumers and business are getting some relief, but inflation remains far too high and not near our price stability goal,” Daly said on Wednesday, after the latest consumer price index report.

“This is why we don’t want to declare victory on inflation coming down,” she said. “We’re not near done yet.”

“We have a lot of work to do. I just don’t want to do it so reactively that we find ourselves spoiling the labour market,” Daly said. She pushed back on rising investor expectations that the Fed will abruptly turn to cutting rates next year. “If we tip the economy over and [people] lose jobs, then we haven’t really made them better off.”

“What we need is not a good report on inflation. It’s encouraging, but it’s not evidence of the goal we really want,” she said. Instead, Daly is looking for the data in the aggregate to affirm the Fed is “on a path to bring inflation down substantially and achieve our price stability target”.

From Reuters (here). “I still think 50 basis points is the case, but I am open to 75 should the data evolve differently,” Daly told Bloomberg TV, saying she does not want to be “head-faked” by the recent improvement in inflation readings and noting there will be more data on employment and inflation before the Fed’s next meeting, on Sept. 20-21.

“We don’t want financial conditions to relax,” Daly said, noting that she looks not only at the stock market but also at borrowing costs for businesses and consumers as well mortgage rates — which have risen sharply — to gauge financial conditions.

“I don’t see this hump-shaped part where we raise interest rates to really high rates and then bring them down,” Daly told Bloomberg TV. “I think of raising them to a level that we think is going to be appropriate and then holding them there.”

Charles L. Evans – Chicago Fed President – Dovish

August 10

From Reuters (here). With consumer prices unchanged last month compared to June, but up 8.5% from a year earlier, inflation is still “unacceptably” high, and the Fed will likely need to lift its policy rate, currently in the 2.25%-2.5% range, to 3.25%-3.5% this year and to 3.75%-4% by the end of next year, Evans said.

“I feel like we’re in a good place and we can pivot to be more restrictive if inflation gets out of hand more than what I’m thinking about,” Evans said at an event at Drake University in Des Moines, Iowa. “But also, if things get better more quickly, we can not raise rates quite as much as I’ve just indicated … I think we’re well-positioned now for a couple of different turns of the data over the next few months.”

Patrick T. Harker – Philadelphia Fed President – Hawkish

No recent statements.

Neel Kashkari – Minneapolis – Dovish

August 10

From Bloomberg (here). “In June, in the Summary of Economic Projections, where all of the FOMC participants put in their own projections of interest rates for the next few years, I recommended being at 3.9% by the end of this year, and 4.4% by the end of the following year,” Kashkari said at an Aspen Institute event Wednesday. “I haven’t seen anything that changes that.”

“I think a much more likely scenario is we will raise rates to some point and then we will sit there until we get convinced that inflation is well on its way back down to 2% before I would think about easing back on interest rates,” he said. 

From Reuters (here). The Fed is “far, far away from declaring victory” on inflation, Kashkari said at the Aspen Ideas Conference, despite the “welcome” news in the consumer price index report earlier in the day that inflation may have begun to cool.

Although Kashkari acknowledged that raising rates so quickly could push the economy into recession, and that a recession could even occur in the “near future,” he said that risk will not deter him. “We have to get back to 2%” inflation, he said.

Kashkari also pushed back on market expectations for rate cuts to begin early next year, saying they are “not realistic.” Rates are not likely to be cut “until we get convinced that inflation is well on its way” to the Fed’s 2% target, he said.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.