The July FOMC was, in our view, a “no change” FOMC compared to the June meeting. The Committee is trying to deliver a soft landing but, as Powell said, “we know that the path has clearly narrowed”. Most importantly, Powell reiterated (twice) that the best guess of the path of the FF rate remains the median of the June SEP dots plot: 3.4% in 2022 and 3.8% in 2023. This path is higher than markets’ expectations (in 2023) and lower than implied by our “main” Phillips curve model (which sees a more persistent inflation path). In our view, the FOMC will not turn dovish over the summer or possibly in 2022. The reason is that there is a slowdown but it is “the slowdown in economic activity that we think we need [to lower inflation]” (Powell’s words).
The dovish pivot is still away and the FF rate cut might be coming in 2023 but not in H1 in our view and estimates.
Q&As
Headline inflation might be coming down given the decline in commodity prices while core inflation might remain elevated. How is the committee thinking about this?
Powell: “Our focus will continue to be on using our tools to bring demand back into a better balance with supply in order to bring inflation back down. That will continue to be our focus. We have also said we expect ongoing rate hikes will be appropriate and that we will make decisions meeting by meeting. So we will be looking at the incoming data and that will start with economic activity, are we seeing the slowdown in economic activity that we think we need, and there is some evidence that we are at this time; of course we will be looking at labor market conditions […] of course we will be looking closely at inflation. Our mandate is for headline, it’s not for core but we look at core because is a better indicator of headline going forward. So, we’ll be looking at both. […] In light of all that data, the question we will be asking is whether the stance of policy we have is sufficiently restrictive to bring inflation back down to our 2% target. […] The Committee broadly feels that we need to bring policy at least to moderately restrictive level. And the best data point for that would be what we wrote down in our SEP at the June meeting: the median for the end of this year would have been between 3¼ and 3½ percent and then people wrote down 50bps higher than that for 2023.”
Comment: Powell has labelled the slowdown in economic activity as “the slowdown in economic activity that we think we need”. Indeed, there is little doubt there are signs of a slowdown. But, in our estimates, without a significant help from the supply side, growth must remain well below potential (or even negative) for a protracted period of time (several quarters) to bring inflation down to 2%. For this reason, we think that that the FOMC will remain committed and keep the FF rate elevated beyond the end of 2022, as implied by the June SEP.
Markets imply some FF rate cuts in 2023. Is this consistent with the financial conditions that you need to bring inflation down to 2%?
Powell: “The best data, the only data point I have for you is the June SEP, […] since then inflation has coming higher, economic activity has coming weaker than expected but at the same time I would say it is probably the best estimate of where the Committee thinking is still; which is, we would get to a moderately restrictive level by the end of this year; by which I mean somewhere between 3 and 3½, and the Committee sees further rate increases in 2023.”
Comment: Again, Powell referred to the June SEP. We note that the path of the FF rate implied by the June SEP is higher (in 2023) than markets’ expectations. We also note that the June SEP forecast is more dovish than implied by our “main” PC model; therefore, it might be revised up in September once again.
Headline and core are likely to send different signals going forward. Which one will you look at?
Powell: “We would be looking at both and we would be asking ourself are we confident that inflation is on a path down to 2%. That’s really the question. And our policy stance will be set at a level ultimately at which we are confident that inflation is going to be moving down to 2%. […] Core inflation is a better predictor going forward. Headline inflation tends to be volatile. So in ordinary times you look through volatile moves in commodities. The problem with the current situation is that if you have a sustained period of supply shocks, those can actually start to undermine or to work to de-anchoring inflation expectations. The public does not distinguish between core and headline in their thinking.”
Comment: In our view, the Fed staff has not deviated from its usual procedures. Therefore, all the analyses are still run using core inflation as benchmark (as confirmed by Powell). Headline inflation will continue to influence households’ expectations. Having said so, headline is unlikely to have an impact on the FOMC even if gasoline prices will continue to come down.
PCE inflation might be sending different signals than CPI inflation going forward. Which one will you look at?
Powell: “We have long used PCE because we think it’s better in capturing inflation that people actually faced in their lives and I think that view is pretty widely understood. That said, the public really reads about CPI and the difference is really that the CPI has a higher weight on things like food, gasoline, motor vehicles, and housing that the PCE does. […] But remember, we do target PCE because we think it is a better measure. They will come together, eventually. The typical gap was 25bps for a very long time and now it is much larger than that because of the things I have mentioned.”
Comment: the CPI-PCE gap is unusually high due to technical factors (different weights, different scope of the two indices, etc..). In our view (and experience), the Fed staff only cares about PCE data and all forecasts contained in the Tealbook are presented in PCE space. For this reason, while the markets will continue to be more focused on CPI data, the Fed (staff) will continue to be focused on PCE data. Having said so, the FOMC is looking for “clear and convincing signs” that inflation is moderating. Despite the methodological differences, it is hard to imagine that the gap will grow further from here. Therefore, for now we can ignore the nuances and concentrate on the substance.