May 2022 FOMC: As Expected

FOMC: 50 is the new 25, 75 shall not.

“Inflation is much too high, and we understand the hardship it is causing, and we’re moving expeditiously to bring it back down”

The outcome of May 2022 FOMC was largely as expected. Powell sent a clear signal: the Fed will not stop until it has convincing evidence that inflation has moderated (“we really want to feel we are making progress there”). At the same time, Powell took off the table the 75bps hike possibility (for the record: the idea of a 75bps hike had already been rejected by FOMC members – see our email on “Recent FOMC Participants Statements Update” on April 24). In other words, 50bps is the new 25bps but 75bps shall not.

Statement

Regarding the statement, the FOMC made two changes. First it stressed that the new lockdowns in China “are likely to exacerbate supply chain disruptions”, which should put additional upper pressure on consumers’ prices going forward. Second, it stressed that “the Committee is highly attentive to inflation risks”.

Comment. Message is clear: Fed knows that the risks are still to the upside. Our analysis (please refer to our “Pre FOMC Meeting Package”) conferms the FOMC view.

Q&As

One month of data (lower inflation, higher unemployment) is enough to change the Fed view?

Powell got a question about high frequency (that is, monthly data at the Fed) and clarified that one month of data is not enough to change the Fed view.

Powell’s words: “One month is not enough, no. One month reading does not tell us much. We want to see evidence that inflation is moving in a direction that is giving us comfort. We have two months now where core inflation is a little lower but we are not looking at that as a reason to take comfort. We really need to see that our expectation is being fulfilled and inflation is in fact under control and starting to come down.”

Replying to a separate question (the one about 75bps hikes), Powell said: “We have seen some evidence that the core PCE inflation is perhaps either reaching the peak or flattening out. We will want to know more than some the evidence, we will really want to feel we are making progress there.” 

Comment: In general, one month of data means very little for the Fed staff and the FOMC. Not only, but Powell said that in the last two months core PCE price inflation was a bite lower than the previous months but that is not a reason to take comfort. The reason (which was probably too much to explain in the press conference) is that the deceleration came from the other than market-based items which tend to be volatile and carry no signal of future core PCE prices readings (see our email updating our Pre FOMC Meeting Package). Not only, but as previously explained, movements in underlying inflation are always more important for the Fed than actual/observed inflation. Finally, about Powell’s words on inflation “flattening out”: we take it as a comment on both, YoY and MoM of core PCE prices. We do agree that the YoY has probably peaked and that the MoM is flattening out. However, the question is not whether it has flattened but where we will land by the end of the year. The good news is that, as previously discussed, the FOMC forecast is now balancing the risks and it is based on the reality of the data.

Is inflation psicology changing?

Powell got a question about whether, in his view, inflation psicology is changing in the economy (in areas like workers wage demand).

Powell’s words: “We don’t really see strong evidence of that yet. But that does not in any way make us comfortable. Look at short-term inflation expectations. They are quite elevated. You can say, well, that is because people expect inflation to come down. In fact, inflation expectations come down sharply. Longer-term inflation expectations have been reasonably stable but only moved to levels where they were in 2014 by some measures. So you can look at that and I think that is a fair description of the picture. But it’s really about the risk. We do not see a wage price spiral. We see companies have the ability to raise prices and they are doing that but there have been price shocks. I think it takes you back to the basic point. We know we need to expeditiously move our policy rates after ranges of more normal, neutral levels”

Comment: We found Powell’s words a bit confusing. In any case, we think the main message in Powell’s words come from the Fed CIE: inflation expectations have been moving up and they are now at the upper bound of the levels consistent with the Fed target. For this reason, in our view, the Chair has stressed that “it’s really about the risk”. And once again, the risks are skewed to the upside.

Has the FOMC outlook for the unemployment forecast changed since March and what does that mean for inflation forecast?

Powell got a question about the outlook for the unemployment rate and its impact on consumers’ prices. Powell hinted that the outlook for the unemployment rate seems unchanged compared to last round. As for the implications on consumers’ prices, Powell replied talking about wage growth.

Powell’s words: “wages matter a fair amount for companies, particularly in the services sector. Wages are running high -the highest they run in quite some time- and they are one good illustration of how tight labor market really is. The fact that wages are running at the highest level in many decades and that’s because of an imbalance between supply and demand in the labor market so we think through our policies, through further healing in the labor market… higher rater for example a vacancy filling and things like that and more people coming back in we like to think that supply and demand will come back into balance and that therefore wage inflation will moderate to still high levels of wage increases but ones that are more consistent with 2% inflation”

Comment: Powell’s words are not surprising. As explained in private meetings, in our view the Fed staff wage decomposition (which seems to be in the back of Powell’s mind) currently suggests that real wage growth is way above structural productivity. For convenience, we report below the ECI growth decomposition chart that in our view the Fed staff has presented this round. According to this decomposition, the growth rate of the Employment Cost Index consistent with a 2% target in core PCE prices is about 3.5% (Q4/Q4) (the model estimates in 2022 2%-ish underlying inflation, 1.15% of structural productivity, and 0.4% from slack). This implies that any read above 3.5% in ECI growth is  either (i) signaling that the estimated fundamentals are wrong (for instance because underlying inflation is already well above 2%) or (ii) is at risk of putting additional upper pressure on consumers prices. Put it differently: ECI growth readings well above 3.5% are either a bad news for the Fed (under (ii)) or a really bad news (under (i)). And that’s why Powell seems so concerned.

Note: the chart shows the Employment Cost Index (ECI) total compensation growth (Q4/Q4 – black line) and the contributions of the fundamentals (underlying inflation, structural productivity, and slack) from our calibrated model.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.