Reality Won For Now, Messy Family Here to Stay. The outcome of the March meeting delivered a few surprises to us. Let us go straight to the core issue: in our assessment, since September 2025 (and more broadly since 2023), the Fed has been somewhat too dovish relative to incoming data and the signals from the models. For example, prior to this meeting (our note here), the FRB-US model was indicating zero rate cuts in both 2026 and 2027—above the March dots. In our view, the division within the FOMC reflects precisely this tension: on one side, those who acknowledge the persistence of inflation, the data, and the model-based signals; on the other, those who continue to discount the data (e.g., through staff assumptions about pi*, or the nature of inflation above target), or who may be influenced by political considerations.
For our part, we will continue to rely on the models, as—despite everything—we believe they have performed well in the current environment. For this reason, we also do not view the number of dissenting votes as a concern. On the contrary, dissent is not only a sign of intellectual independence but, in our experience, one of the key factors that helps prevent policy mistakes (you must have a smart contrarian in the room). Thus, the fact that the FOMC is divided is not, in our view, a sign of weakness—quite the opposite. Of course, the key question remains the ability of the new Chair to provide leadership and build consensus. Time will tell.
Finally, we are somewhat puzzled by Powell’s decision to remain, and we believe this may increase tensions with the political sphere. Our expectation—and, in some sense, our hope—is that Powell may remain as a governor only for a limited period. Ultimately, in our view, he has already provided a clear path for a transition, should politicians choose to act on it.
Putting everything together: we continue to think that the Fed is on-hold. The bar for a hike remains very high (core PCE needs to run above 3.5% – our note here), and the bar for a cut has finally gone up again tonight to where it should have been.
Statement
The new statement is not surprising in our view and largely reflects incoming data. That said, the real news is that the statement drew the highest number of dissenting votes since October 1992 (as already discussed at the beginning of this note).
Q&As
Question: Can you look through an energy shock? If so, under what conditions?
Powell. “You know, I would look at it this way. For a long time, we’ve been working on the hypothesis, really, that tariffs would lead to a one-time price increase and that that would go away over time. In other words, there would be no further change, so measured inflation wouldn’t reflect that higher level going up more and more. And it’s time for that to happen. We really do expect that to be happening in the next two quarters. So we’ll be watching very carefully to see that what we’ve thought all along would happen—that’s the kind of critical part of the forecast. We need to really see that.
With energy, it’s so hard to say. I mentioned, you know, in sort of the textbook, you would look through an oil shock because they tend to be short-lived and they tend to revert, and monetary policy works with long and variable lags. So, you know, you wouldn’t necessarily react right away.
I think that is all the more true, given that we’re several years above 2% inflation, and that we’re already looking through the tariff shock. So I think we’re going to be very cautious about that.
But the question about looking through energy really is not in front of us right now. It hasn’t even peaked yet. And I think we’d want to see the backside of that and progress on tariffs before we even thought about reducing rates..”
Comment: We agree with Powell here. We think the Fed is trying to look through the energy shock. The real puzzle is the persistency of inflation before the current shock.
Question: Is the easing bias still correct, given that the inflation outlook has changed?
Powell. “That was, as you will recall, we had a discussion about that at the last meeting, and we talked about it in the press conference after the March meeting. We had the same today. We had quite a vigorous discussion about that very issue and the guidance—whether it is still appropriate and that kind of thing.
And I would say that the number of people on the committee who either could support that language change—changing to a more neutral stance so that a hike is as likely as a cut—that number has increased over the intervening period. And it’s easy to see why.
I mean, it’s a good question. You see inflation has moved up over the interim a bit. Core inflation is 3.2 now, moving—albeit just a little bit—in the wrong direction. And we know that there will be, you know, that there’s headline inflation coming out of the Gulf, and we don’t know how much that will be. We’re going to need to see.
So it makes all the sense in the world that people would look at that, and we’d have a vigorous discussion about that. You saw the three people dissent over the language. I think all of those people agreed with the rate decision.
So the majority of the committee did not want to do that. And I didn’t think we needed to do it at this meeting. It really was just a question of: why do we need to do that now?
You know, we have so much to learn. There’s so much uncertainty about the path ahead. There doesn’t need to be any rush to make that decision now because, you know, what happens in the next 30, 60 days—even by the next meeting—could really change the picture around that language.
So, you know, it’s a much closer thing on the committee than it was in March. And, you know, that makes all the sense in the world, it seems to me.”
Comment: Lots of words to say “no, the easing bias is not justified, given how high inflation is”. Not only but to our eyes the most important thing is that Powell said “the majority of the committee did not want to do that”, which seems to imply additional dissidents among non-voters.
Question: What is the passthrough of oil to core prices?
Powell. “Prospects are real. Remember, though, the real thing is we’re going to have to wait and see. We’re going to need to see. And the good news is we think our policy stance is just in a very good place for us to wait and see.
We’re, you know, right kind of at the high end of neutral or perhaps mildly restrictive. The labor market shows more and more signs of stability, whereas inflation is kind of misbehaving. And so maybe a little bit of restriction, or the high end of neutral, is just the right place to be.
So we can wait here and see how things work out before we act. And we’ll see how much of that, you know, how much does come through in the core. You see it already in airfares, of course, but you may see it in many other places—we just don’t know yet.
And it’s so unknowable because how long will the strait be closed? You can develop any number of scenarios that you want, but we really won’t know till we know.
So fortunately, we’re in a good place to wait and let things develop.”
Comment: Translated: they are not sure, and they need to wait and see. The passthrough is generally small, but in the current environment it can be larger. Easy to say they cannot conclude anything right now.