Fed Minutes: Fed Staff Doing Its Part

To keep in mind

Until recently, in our view the Fed staff set the level of underlying inflation to 1.8 percent constant both in history and in the forecast. The newly released minutes reveal that either the staff is assuming that the inflationary process will be more persistent than previously anticipated (without, however, translating on higher expectations), or that the level of underlying inflation is expected to be above target in 2023-2024. Put it differently: the Fed staff has made either a hawkish call or a very hawkish call. In our view it is the latter; as such, we expect a very aggressive monetary policy.

The Fed Staff forecast

According to the minutes, the Russian invasion of Ukraine was perceived by the staff as “adding to the uncertainty around the outlook for economic activity and inflation, as the conflict carried the risk of further exacerbating supply chain disruptions and of putting additional upward pressure on inflation by boosting the prices for energy, food, and other key commodities”. The staff’s near-term projection for PCE price inflation was revised up considerably relative to January. The upward revision reflected the staff’s reaction to the persistently high and broad-based levels of domestic inflation, import price inflation, and wage growth that had been observed, as well as the staff’s expectation that the upward pressure on inflation from supply and demand imbalances would last longer than previously assumed. Total PCE price inflation was projected to be 4 percent in 2022. PCE price inflation was then expected to slow to 2.3 percent in 2023 and to 2.1 percent in 2024 as food, energy, and import price inflation moved lower and as supply and demand imbalances were resolved.

Discussion

The staff has finally given up and admitted the reality of the incoming data. The fact that the staff is now projecting total PCE price inflation at 4 percent (Q4/Q4) in 2022 in our view suggests that the staff has written down a forecast for core PCE price inflation of 3.7 percent in the last Tealbook. As previously communicated, we currently see a 3¾ percent forecast for core PCE price inflation in 2022 as roughly balanced, therefore we welcome the Fed staff revision. However, the most interesting part of the new forecast is what the staff expects in 2023 and 2024. According to the minutes, the staff has revised up the 2023 forecast by 3 tenths, while leaving the 2024 forecast unrevised (at 2.1 percent). The upward revision in 2022 is driven by the strength of the incoming data. But what explains the upward revision in 2023? There are two possibilities in our view.

First explanation – not likely

The first possibility (that we do not see as the most likely) is that the Fed staff has assumed supply-side issues will persist somehow in 2023. The figure and table below show the core PCE price decomposition under this assumption. In this scenario, underlying inflation gradually converges from 1.8 percent in 2020 to 2.0 percent in 2024. At the same time, the “other line” (that is, the part of core inflation that cannot be explained by the fundamentals) is positive and large in 2021 and 2022, and remains positive in 2023. Put it differently, under this scenario the Fed staff would tell the committee that inflation will (somewhat) be more persistent than previously assumed (although the long-term dynamics would still converge to target), therefore suggesting a more aggressive policy action.

Figure and Table Decomposition under first explanation

Second explanation – most likely

The large residual (“other factors”) in 2023 implied by the first explanation leads us to think that the Fed staff has decided to revised the judgmental forecast more in depth. Specifically, in our view the Fed staff has revised the level of underlying inflation more substantially than under the first explanation, possibly following the same rule that governs the long-term inflation dynamic in FRB-US model (the so called “PTR”). Under the PTR rule, pi* evolves according to a process with an error-correction flavor:

Under this assumption, pi* evolves according to observed inflation (pi(t-1)), assuming that monetary policy is committed to bring it back to target at some point. Using this rule, pi* is estimated above target in 2021, reaches 2.3 percent in 2022 and converges back close to target in 2024. In this scenario, there is no unexplained part in 2023, consistent with the traditional Fed staff procedures. Under this scenario the Fed staff would tell the committee that inflation is not persistent but that the currently elevated readings are at risk of de-anchoring expectations. So far, the impact is limited (that is, the movement in underlying inflation is small) but can become more significant with additional upward surprises from incoming data.

Figure and Table Decomposition under second explanation

(Note: in our view, as explained in the past, three pillars inform the Fed staff about the level of pi*: measures of trend inflation, measures of long-term inflation expectations, and the general equilibrium approach. The PTR rule is an equation that in our view helps the Fed staff to implement the suggestions from the three pillars into the judgmental forecast)

To sum up

In our view, the new Fed staff forecast reveals that the staff is having issues in decomposing the current and future expected inflation dynamics with its traditional calibrated model. For this reason, in our view the Fed staff has been under pressure to revise the decomposition significantly in some dimension. Under the most plausible new decomposition, in our view the Fed staff has communicated the message that underlying inflation is on the move and is it possibly already above target.

As we have explained in our April 1st post (“Underlying Inflation, the Fed Staff and The Risk of Losing the War”), there were already clear signals that pi* might be above target and that at this point the elevated inflation is a threat for de-anchoring expectations. In our April 1st post we wrote “The staff should recognize the risks and prevent losing the war”. It seems that the staff has finally done so.

The FOMC will have no mercy, it should not, given what is at stake. 50bps hike and aggressive QT should be taken for given at the May meeting.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.