The outcome of the March Governing Council meeting was in line with our expectations. First, the new staff forecasts are broadly consistent with our model-based projections. The only notable difference is that the forecast for headline HICP is somewhat higher in 2026, while the core HICP forecast is essentially identical. Energy prices have, of course, risen again, placing us somewhere between the baseline and the “adverse” scenarios presented in the staff projections. Even in the adverse scenario, however, the annual average for core HICP appears to be only a few tenths higher than in the baseline, and importantly, core inflation still returns to the 2 percent target.
As for the President’s remarks, we found the tone to be overall balanced. While no scenario can be ruled out, the prevailing impression remains that of an ECB in a holding pattern, waiting for further clarity from incoming data.
More generally, regarding the mechanics of the forecasts, our view is that in the current environment—very different from that of 2022—it is not straightforward to generate a meaningful and persistent increase in core inflation without significant upside surprises in the data. In particular, models are likely, at least for several months, to deliver a response concentrated in the short term: higher inflation for a few months, followed by a return to target over the medium term. The main concern is that some governments are currently reassessing their fiscal stance. This is, as we have consistently argued, the key variable that could turn an energy shock into a more persistent inflationary process. In this regard, we refer the reader to a very insightful article by John Cochrane (link).
Putting everything together, the situation remains a close call to us. Ultimately, the issue is relatively straightforward: for a rate hike, the Governing Council would need to see clear evidence in the data—either in wage dynamics, in inflation expectations, or in the medium-term forecast for core HICP. While a rate hike cannot be ruled out, in our view it is more likely that, if it were to occur, it would happen later than what is currently priced in by the market.
The new forecast
Broadly as expected. The new ECB/NCB staff forecasts are very close to our model-based projections. The direction of the revisions is broadly in line with expectations. The only notable difference is that headline HICP is somewhat higher than in our models for 2026, while core HICP is essentially identical. See Figure 1 below. (That said, energy prices have continued to rise, including this morning. It is therefore reasonable to expect further upward revisions to headline inflation.)
Figure 1.Comparison: Underlying Inflation forecast vs ECB/NCBs staff forecast.
Initial Statement
Lagarde: “We are well positioned to navigate this uncertainty. Inflation has been at around our 2% target, longer-term inflation expectations are well anchored, and the economy has shown resilience over recent quarters. […] The implications for medium-term inflation depend crucially on the magnitude of indirect and second-round effects of a stronger and more persistent energy shock. […] Indicators of underlying inflation have changed little over recent months and remain consistent with our 2% medium-term target. […] Negotiated wage growth and forward-looking indicators, such as the ECB wage tracker and surveys on wage expectations, suggest that labor costs will ease further in the course of 2026, which should support the return of inflation to target.”
Our comment: Our impression from listening to Lagarde is that there is currently no sense of urgency within the Governing Council to raise interest rates, as inflation expectations remain consistent with the target and second-round effects appear to be very limited.
Q&A
Question. What would trigger an ECB hike?
Lagarde: “I hope everybody else will be patient, because I might take a little longer than I normally take, but I hope it informs all of you. So, as I said, we will continue to apply the three key principles that I have outlined. And being data dependent will lead us to look at everything that we normally look at. But we will be particularly attentive to a number of things, and that’s, I think, the point in your question.
We will be particularly attentive to developments in all commodity markets. We will be particularly attentive to supply bottlenecks. We will be particularly attentive to selling price expectations of firms. And, you know, through the corporate telephone survey in particular and other surveys that we hold in good value, we can assess how often price revisions will take place. That will be important. We will be particularly attentive to all demand indicators, you know, be it PMIs, consumer confidence, etc. We will be particularly attentive to wage trackers.
Because what we want to really come back to is these three key points that I have mentioned and that are also in the monetary policy statement. All of that which is unfolding at the moment, which is a severe shock, will depend on the duration, the intensity, and the propagation. And by propagation, I mean the indirect effects and the second-round effects.
And we need to have the best senses and the best way to anticipate where these indirect effects and where these second-round effects are going, if at all. That’s what we will be attentive to.”
Our comment: This response is rather vague. More simply, we believe that for the Governing Council to act, it would need to see in the data: (i) a core HICP forecast clearly above target (a one-tenth deviation is obviously insufficient), (ii) a re-acceleration in wage growth, and/or (iii) an increase in long-term inflation expectations. At present, none of these conditions are in place, and it is not clear when they might materialize.
Question. Core is above 2% in the forecast. Why? And how do you feel about it?
Lagarde: “I’m proud of the projections that have been delivered. Granted, on core, we are 2.1 in 2028. You have to remember that we include in that ETS2, applying as of 2028, and you still have a little bit of remaining of the base effect and a little bit of second round.”
Our comment: This suggests that a deviation of one tenth (or even a few tenths) of core HICP from target is not sufficient to generate concern—or to justify a rate hike.
Question. Is the oil passthrough to core inflation changed compared to the past?
Lagarde: “Well, thank you for your question. You know, we have a lot of difference with 2022. I think another point that we have to keep in mind is that back in 2022, when the shock hit, inflation was already at 6%. So that’s a big difference with where we are at the moment, where the latest reading was 1.9, and we had inflation at target in the medium term.
So that’s a major difference. I think the labor market is also quite a bit different. And I’m not saying that to avoid your question, but I think all this actually matters. And the fact that we have a labor market which is, you know, solid, but not as hot as it was back in ’22, where we had, you know, shortages of labor and a different bargaining position, will also play a role. Caveat, though, inflation expectations have a lot to do with the memory that people, corporates have of inflation. And back in ’22, the memory was, you know, dating way back. Now the memory is rather fresh, because people have seen inflation.
So the reaction function that they will have in terms of investment, in terms of wages, negotiations, in terms of consumption, that is going to be informed by fresher memory of inflation that went high and that we managed to bring back to 2%. I think the third element which is different as well, and that we will have to be attentive to, is that while it was a major supply shock to begin with in ’22, we had the pent-up demand and a demand shock element about the situation that we faced.”
Our comment: This is also our impression. Current conditions are very different from those in 2022, and for now the Governing Council appears to be broadly aligned with our view.