A Productivity Shock!
The outcome of the December FOMC meeting was broadly in line with expectations—both in terms of the policy action (a 25-basis-point rate cut) and the updated SEP. The key takeaway, however, lies not in the decision itself but in the underlying (dovish) message conveyed by Chair Powell and, implicitly, by the SEP.
Although the Committee was notably divided—with three dissents and several members expressing different views—the SEP implicitly delivers a strong signal: growth was revised significantly higher, particularly for 2026, without any corresponding downward revision in the unemployment rate or upward pressure on inflation. (please, note that FRB-US has been consistently more optimistic than the FOMC about real GDP growth).
The only coherent way to rationalize this configuration is through Powell’s remarks on a possible productivity boom. FRB-US has been indicating a productivity shock for some time, and readers can find our previous notes on the subject here and here. It is noteworthy that the FOMC has now arrived at this conclusion in the current round, sending a clear message to markets. To us, at this point, it makes sense to focus on what the model has been signalling for months—that growth would be stronger than the Fed expected, and that the unemployment rate would not face significant upward risks (with upside risks for inflation persistence).
Overall, this is unequivocally good news for the U.S. economy. The Fed may cut rates again in early 2026, but at this point such a move would likely require materially negative developments in the labor market over the coming weeks.
Statement
The new statement is neutral. We see no significan changes for the topics we cover.
The dots
Higher Growth, No Inflation Pressure. Figure 1 compares the September SEP (blue line), the pre-FOMC FRB-US model run (red line), and the December SEP (blue dots). As mentioned, no big surprises, except for higher growth (please, note that the model was above the September SEP).
Figure 1. Comparison between the September SEP (blue line), pre-FOMC FRB-US model run (red line), and the December SEP (blue dots).
Q&As
Question: Why is real GDP growth in 2026 so high?
Powell. “A number of things are driving what’s happening in the forecast. And I would say, if you look broadly at outside forecasts, you do see a pickup in growth in many of those now too. So it is partly that consumer spending is held up, it’s been resilient, and it is that AI spending on data centers and related to AI has been holding up business investment. So overall, the baseline expectation for next year is […] a pick up in growth from today’s relatively low level of level of 1.7%. I mentioned that the SEP medium is 1.7% for this year growth and 2.3 for next year. Actually, some of that is due to the shutdown: you can take two tenths out of 2026 and put it in 2025. So it would really be 1.9% and 2.1%. But overall, fiscal policy is going to be supportive and as I mentioned, the consumer continues to spend so it looks like the baseline would be solid growth next year.”
Comment: As mentioned above, to us the key message here is the word “productivity”. Everything else is minor.
Question: Why did you move today rather than in January?
Powell. “Inflation has come in a touch lower and I think the evidence is growing that what’s happening here is services inflation coming down and that’s offset by increases in goods; and that goods inflation is entirely in sectors where they’re tariffs. So that does build on the story. And so far it’s only a story that this is goods inflation, which is really the source of the excess at this point… more than half the source of the excess inflation is goods is tariffs. […] I would say that […] it doesn’t feel like a hot economy that wants to generate, you know, Philips curve kind of inflation.”
Comment: We cannot totally disagree with Powell here but: (1) very hard to say anything with no data (and this will continue for several months, given the possible issues with data quality), and (2) it is in any case weird that we are still at 3% and that the last time we were at target was 50 months ago. Whether Powell wants to admit it or not, there is something in this story he (we) cannot explain at the moment.
Question: This is the 3rd time you cut with inflation at 3%. Are you sending a message that you are ok at this level?
Powell gave a very long answer that can be summarized as follows: the Fed cannot focus entirely on inflation right now because there are downside risks to the labor market.
Comment: We cannot disagree with Powell. But it is very hard to square his words with the new SEP. How can there be significant downside risks to the labor market if growth is revised up so much (even considering a possible productivity shock)?
Question: Is the Fed on hold?
Powell. “I would note that having reduced our policy rate by 75 basis points since September and 175 basis points since last September, the Fed funds rate is now within a broad range of estimates of its neutral value. And we are well positioned to wait to see how the economy evolves.”
Comment: To us, the bar for a rate cut in January is now elevated, unless we will get a significant downward surprise in the data in the next few weeks.