We have conducted a new update of the FRB-US model. This iteration incorporates two key pieces of information: the September labor market report and our revised assumption for third-quarter growth. Specifically, we have decided to lower our estimate for Q3 GDP growth and align it more closely with the most recent forecasts from professional forecasters. We now assume that the U.S. economy grew at an annualized rate of approximately 2.5 percent in the third quarter. The current model baseline is unlikely to change going into the December FOMC.
Updated baseline
The model now projects slightly weaker growth for the year (although still stronger than in the September SEP), and a modestly higher unemployment rate—around 0.1 percentage point (to rounding) above previous estimates. Inflation, by contrast, remains unchanged, with the forecast essentially identical to the prior runs.
Taken together, these revisions yield a federal funds rate path that is marginally more dovish than before. That said, even with these new inputs, the model continues to show no rate cuts in the fourth quarter, and the baseline remains above the September SEP path.
In short, even within the model framework, a rate cut in the near term has become a very close call. Ultimately, as far as the December SEP is concerned, we continue to believe that the final decision will be a judgmental one by Chair Powell.
Figure 1. Update FRB-US forecast – real-side variables.
Note: Real GDP growth and core inflation are expressed on a year-over-year basis. Core inflation refers to core PCE price inflation. The red-solid lines are the model forecast under an inertial Taylor rule, the red-dashed lines are the model baseline using a non-inertial Taylor rule, while the blue dots are the September SEP. The baseline has been updated as outlined in the text.
SPF and the Fed Staff
Starting with the Survey of Professional Forecasters (SPF) from the Philadelphia Fed, inflation forecasts have been revised significantly higher. We are not surprised by this outcome. In fact, our models have been running above consensus—including that of professional forecasters—for quite some time. What has happened is essentially that the professional forecasters have now closed most of the gap with our models, particularly in CPI space. For example, the SPF’s forecast for core CPI inflation is now identical to that of our main model (latest summary table with our models forecast is here). The only remaining divergence lies in PCE space, where our models continue to project somewhat higher inflation than the SPF.
Turning to the Fed staff, yesterday’s release of the October meeting minutes contained one notable passage: the acknowledgment that “more than four consecutive years of actual inflation above 2 percent raised the possibility that this year’s projected rise in inflation would prove to be more persistent than the staff anticipated”. (Also, according to the minutes, the Fed staff has revised up the forecast of real GDP growth “reflecting stronger expected potential output growth”). We do not know precisely what motivated this shift, nor which factors drove the staff’s reassessment. Nonetheless, this adjustment is a welcome one. As we have argued before, we see the inflation process as more persistent than the Fed staff’s baseline implies, and it is plausible that the staff itself has now begun to share some of these concerns. As for the upward revision to potential, we are also not surprised, as FRB flagged it long time ago (our note here).