FOMC participants communication: rationality is back.
An update on the latest FOMC participants’ statements on inflation and possible path for monetary policy.
We have heard from: Brainard, Williams, Bullard, Mester, Daly, and Evans.
Keep in mind
As expected, Bullard is out of consensus and remains an outlier. All other participants (notably Brainard and Williams) expressed a preference for a gradual start (25bps in March) followed by a sequence of hikes. The impression is that most participants do not have a clear idea of how many hikes the FOMC will deliver in 2022 because uncertainty around the inflation outlook remains elevated (on this point, please recall our scenarios analysis for the level of durable goods prices which remains crucial – you can find the post here).
We never bought the possibility that the FOMC could begin with a 50bps hike in March, not even when markets were pricing 90%+ probability, as discussed in our latest update. We continue to believe that a gradual approach in H1 is more reasonable even if core inflation is running way above target. As such, in our view this week participants’ statements have brought some rationality back to the table.
FOMC-meter
Dovish
Leal Brainard
John Williams
Charles Evans
Mary C. Daly
Neel Kashkari
Neutral
Jerome H. Powell
Michelle W. Bowman
Thomas I. Barkin
Hawkish
Christopher Waller
James Bullard
Esther L. George
Loretta J. Mester
Raphael Bostic
Patrick T. Harker
Note: FOMC voters are bolded.
Recent FOMC participants' statements - most recent statements in blue
Jerome H. Powell – Chair – Dovish
No recent statements.
Lael Brainard – Governor – Dovish
February 19
From Bloomberg (here). “Given we have seen quite strong data, I do anticipate it will be appropriate at our next meeting to initiate a series of rate increases,” Brainard said Friday during a panel discussion at a conference in New York hosted by the University of Chicago Booth School of Business. “We have a recovery today that is much stronger and faster than in the last cycle. So I do believe it will be appropriate to commence that runoff in the next few meetings,” added Brainard. Brainard said raising rates and running down the balance sheet “will bring down inflation over time.”
Christopher J. Waller – Governor – Hawkish
No recent statements.
Michelle W. Bowman – Governor – Neutral
No recent statements.
John C. Williams – New York Fed President – Dovish
February 18
From NY Fed (here). “This sudden, sharp rise in prices reflects a unique set of circumstances that has driven supply and demand out of balance.” […] “In addition, we have seen a large pullback in the number of people willing and able to work, in part reflecting the challenges and risks of working during the pandemic. Some businesses can’t hire people fast enough to help meet the strong demand. This has contributed to an acceleration in wages and higher prices for a variety of goods and services, including food and housing.” […] “But with today’s strong economy and inflation that is well above our 2 percent longer-run goal, it is time to start the process of steadily moving the target range back to more normal levels. In particular, I expect it will be appropriate to raise the target range at our upcoming meeting in March. Once the interest rate increases are underway, the next step will be to start the process of steadily and predictably reducing our holdings of Treasury and mortgage-based securities, which had grown significantly as a result of the purchases that began in March 2020. Last month, the FOMC released a set of principles that will guide that process. Assuming the economy develops roughly as I expect, I foresee this process getting started later this year.” […] “My forecast for the U.S. economy is for real GDP to grow a bit below 3 percent this year, for the unemployment rate to end the year around 3-1/2 percent, and for PCE price inflationto drop back to around 3 percent, before falling further next year as supply issues continue to recede.”
From Reuters (here). “I don’t see any compelling argument to taking a big step at the beginning,” Williams told reporters on Friday. “I think we can steadily move up interest rates and reassess.”
Fed Presidents with voting power in 2022
James Bullard – St. Louis Fed President – Hawkish
February 17
From St. Louis Fed (here).“This is a moment where we need to shift to less accommodation, and the debate is about how fast to do that,” he said. “That does mean we would have to move faster and more nimbly than we have in recent decades, but I think that’s probably the appropriate policy,” he said. Bullard also addressed the idea that raising the policy rate would risk recession. “This is just talking about the very first moves from an extremely accommodative policy that we used during the pandemic, and I don’t think those first moves are very likely to tip the economy into recession,” he said.
From CNBC (here). “We’re at more risk now than we’ve been in a generation that this could get out of control,” he said during a panel talk at Columbia University. “One scenario would be … a new surprise that hits us that we can’t anticipate right now, but we would have even more inflation. That’s the kind of situation that we want to … make sure it doesn’t occur.” […] “Overall, I’d say there’s been too much emphasis and too much mindshare devoted to the idea that inflation will dissipate at some point in the future,” Bullard said. “We’re at risk that inflation won’t dissipate, and 2022 will be the second year in a row of quite high inflation. So that’s why given this situation, the Fed should move faster and more aggressively than we would have in other circumstances.” Bullard said the upcoming change in policy shouldn’t be viewed as an attempt to restrict the markets and the economy. “It’s not tight policy. Don’t let anybody tell you it’s tight policy,” he said. “It’s removal of accommodation that will signal that we take our responsibility seriously.”
Esther L. George – Kansas City Fed President – Hawkish
No recent statements.
Loretta J. Mester – Cleveland Fed President – Neutral
February 17
From Cleveland Fed (here): “I do expect some improvement in inflation readings later in the year as demand moderates and capacity constraints in both product and labor markets begin to ease. Nonetheless, I expect inflation to remain above 2 percent this year and next, and I see the risks to inflation as tilted to the upside. My projection of some moderation in inflation is conditioned on the FOMC taking appropriate action to transition away from the current emergency levels of accommodation and recalibrate to an economy in which inflation has been running well above our 2 percent goal for some time, labor markets are very strong, and solid momentum in underlying demand is expected to continue.” […]
“While the experience after the Great Recession will inform this transition, the economy is in a very different place, so the transition will be different, too. As monetary policy transitions, our policy communications will also need to transition away from explicit forward guidance and toward conveying a sense of our policy trajectory and explaining the rationale for our policy decisions in terms of economic and financial developments and their implications for the outlook and risks around the outlook.“
“Barring an unexpected turn in the economy, I believe it will be appropriate to move the funds rate up in March and follow with further increases in the coming months. If by mid-year, I assess that inflation is not going to moderate as expected, then I would support removing accommodation at a faster pace over the second half of the year. On the other hand, if inflation moves down faster than expected, then the pace of removal could be slower in the second half of the year than in the first half. So, the pace at which monetary policy accommodation is removed will need to be data driven and forward looking. The communications challenge will be to convey a good sense of how policy is likely to respond conditional on how the economy evolves without implying that policy is pre-committed to a particular path regardless of how the economy evolves.”
“So, barring a material change in the economy, I anticipate that it will be appropriate to move the funds rate up at a faster pace this time and to begin reducing the size of the balance sheet soon and more quickly than last time. In terms of the balance sheet, I would also support selling some of our mortgage-backed securities at some point during the reduction process, something we did not do last time. Sales would help to speed the return of our portfolio’s composition to primarily Treasury securities, which would minimize the effect of our balance-sheet holdings on the allocation of credit across economic sectors, one of the FOMC’s principles for reducing the size of our balance sheet.”
Fed Presidents with no voting power in 2022
Thomas I. Barkin – Richmond Fed President – Neutral
No recent statements.
Raphael Bostic – Atlanta Fed President – Hawkish
No recent statements.
Mary C. Daly – San Francisco Fed President – Dovish
February 13
From Reuters (here): “So I look at the data, and I see that it is obvious that we need to pull some of the accommodation out of the economy, but history tells us with Fed policy that abrupt and aggressive action can actually have a destabilizing effect on the very growth and price stability that we’re trying to achieve,” Daly told CBS’ “Face The Nation” in an interview.
Charles L. Evans – Chicago Fed President – Dovish
February 18
From Chicago Fed (here): “Our present monetary policy setting is wrong-footed against the current, sharp increase in inflation. That is for sure. But the sources of these large relative price increases may be different from more typical cyclical inflation episodes. Furthermore, by my reading, underlying inflation appears to still be well anchored at levels consistent with the Fed’s average 2 percent objective, and so—unlike in the Volker and Greenspan eras—no extra monetary restraint is needed to bring trend inflation down. So I see our current policy situation as likely requiring less ultimate financial restrictiveness compared with past episodes and posing a smaller risk to the employment mandate than many times in the past. That said, I recognize there is not a clean orthogonal decomposition between cyclical and underlying inflation, and we need to monitor developments carefully to make sure the current spike in inflation does not bleed over into an unwelcome increase in the underlying trend. If it does, more restrictive policy will be needed.” […] “We don’t know what is on the other side of the current inflation spike, but if a low r* world reemerges, we may once again be looking at a situation where there is nothing to fear from running the economy hot. And there are important benefits of doing so.”
“With regard to the policy situation today, I still see current inflation as largely being driven by unusual supply-side developments related to the Covid-19 shock. But inflation pressures clearly have widened in the broader economy to a degree that requires a substantial repositioning of monetary policy. What that repositioning ultimately will look like will depend a good deal on the same factors that enter the running-hot calculus.”
Patrick T. Harker – Philadelphia Fed President – Hawkish
No recent statements.
Neel Kashkari – Minneapolis – Dovish
No recent statements.