Take the Summer Off
The “totality of the data” remains too strong. We expect the Fed to take the Summer off to think about it. Compared to the time of the March SEP, the inflation data have surprised to the upside while real GDP growth seems just a touch weaker. We expect the new dots to show real GDP growth marginally lower in 2024 (at or just below 2%), and core PCE marginally higher in 2024 (to 2.7%-2.8%). We do not expect meaningful revisions to the unemployment rate path in the new SEP. Risks are to the upside for core PCE in 2025 (from 2.2% to 2.3%) and for the longer run dot (from 2.6% to 2.7%). As for the FF rate, the Taylor rules signal upside risks throughout the entire forecast horizon (for instance, FRB-US expects only one cut in 2024). Putting everything together, the impression is that it is still too early for the Fed to signal a real intention to cut rates: economic activity does not show meaningful weakness, and core prices remain well above target (including the estimate of pi* at 2.5%). In this circumstances, the wisest thing the Fed can do is to take time and postpone the discussion.
Main points:
- The incoming data have been a bit stronger than expected by the Fed staff forecast inferred from the latest FOMC minutes. We estimate that the upward surprise is about 1 tenth to rounding (in core PCE space). The distribution of price changes remains consistent with readings above target in both, core CPI and core PCE space.
Figure 1. Core CPI MoM prices change distributions.
- The medium-term forecast and pi* are little changed. The medium-term model-based forecast is revised up a bit, as the incoming data were stronger than the model expected. The estimate of pi* is marginally lower (at 2.5%) than last round but remains well above target.
Figure 2. Current and previous FOMC round “main” model forecast of core PCE price inflation.
Figure 3. Comparison of the evolution of the 2024 (Q4/Q4) core PCE price inflation forecast.
- The estimate of “underlying inflation” (pi*), the crucial variable in the Fed staff forecast, remains above target. In our view, the Fed staff is estimating pi* at 2.5%. This round, the estimate of pi* is revised down (to rounding). Pi* is very persistent by nature; until the estimate of pi* will be lower and close to target, it will be hard to imagine a real dovish Fed.
- The Taylor rules signal upside risks around the March SEP. Both the Fed staff (2021) rule and the inertial Taylor rule (1999) are a bit above the March SEP, especially at the end of the forecast horizon (see PDF package). FRB-US projects the FF rate at 5.15% in 2024 (conditional on Q2 real GDP growth at 2.4% QoQ saar), 4.4% in 2025, and 3.6% in 2026. Assuming a lower growth in Q2 (2.0%) results in the FF rate at 5.1% in 2024 and the YoY of real GDP growth at 1.75% in 2024:Q4.
Figure 4. Latest FRB-US forecast (red dashed line) vs latest SEP (blue solid line).
As usual, we would be more than happy to schedule a meeting to discuss the details.