3% Is The New 2%
There is a Phillips Curve! Back in July 2023 (our note here) we argued that the behavior of the ECI was consistent with a Phillips curve model. Then, in October 2023 the data reinforced the message (our note here). Today is part III of this act. Yes, the data were stronger than the model expected but today’s surprise offset the one of the previous quarter entirely. Indeed, the YoY of the ECI (total compensation, private industry workers) came in at 4.1%, that is what the model expected for 2024:Q1 back in July 2023 (!) and also in October 2023 (again, see here and here). Despite what the critics say, it is almost impossible to find a better model.
In a nutshell: the road is bumpy, but today’s data changes little for the Fed, as wage growth remains more consistent with 3% readings in consumers’ prices space. No need to hike, just “for longer”.
The incoming data
According to the BLS, over the three months ending in March, total compensation for private industry workers increased 4.5% QoQ (a.r.) and 4.1 percent YoY. Wages and salaries increased 4.3 percent for the 12-month period ending in March, while benefit costs increased 3.6 percent. The NSA level of the series by year can be seen here.
Our model-based forecast
The inclusion of the first quarter in the sample resulted in a higher forecast. Figure 1 (right panel) shows a comparison between the current forecast, the published figures, and the previous forecast (the one in real-time post Q4 numbers). The data were stronger than expected; the model took signal from the data and revised up the entire forecast. The YoY of ECI total compensation for private industry is now projected at 4.1 percent in 2023:Q4 and to remain around 3½ percent by the end of the forecast period.
The message is clear: yes, the labor market is not as tight as it was in 2022. But overall, wage growth remains more consistent with a 3% consumers’ price inflation than 2%.
Figure 1. Phillips curve model-based ECI forecast
Current forecast, model-based
Comparison: current vs. previous forecast (QoQ and YoY)
Note: the figure shows the ECI Phillips curve model-based forecast (YoY). The chart refers to the year-over-year percent changes of compensation costs for private industry workers. The confidence intervals are based on the estimated parameters distributions. The table on the right shows a comparison between the current forecast (2024:Q1 last quarter in-sample) and the previous forecast (real-time in 2023:Q4).
An heterodox Phillips curve
An heterodox Phillips curve continues to suggest there is no free lunch: wage growth disinflates when labor market cools off. Figure 2 shows what can be labeled as “an heterodox Phillips curve”. The figure shows the relation between ECI total compensation growth and an ad-hoc measure of “slack”: the difference between the unemployment rate and the jobs opening rate. The idea is that we remain agnostic about the current slope of the Beveridge curve. While it is unclear what side of the Beveridge curve will dominate going forward, a convincing disinflation that brings ECI growth to about 3% requires our measure of “slack” to be around 0. This means that we have at least another 1 to 1.5pp of disinflation to achieve, either side of the Beveridge curve, before wage growth can return to a level consistent with the Fed target. The good news is that there is no mystery through the lens of this “heterodox” Phillips curve: ECI growth is (more or less) where it should be.
Figure 2. An heterodox ECI Phillips curve.