Preamble: we are delaying the release of our Pre-FOMC Meeting Package after the CPI report. Please, get in touch in case you would like to get earlier updates. In any case, conditional on today’s information set, it seems that the dots could show either no changes to the FF rate in 2024 or one cut less than in the December SEP.
In our estimates, the February AHE reading understates the “true” pace of wage growth. Last month (our note is here), we argued that the large MoM increase was distorted by a drop in hours and some sectoral shifts. In retrospective, given the (very) low reading in February, we think it was the right call. In this note, we show that according to our model, net of residual calendarity issues and sectoral shifts, the “true” AHE growth rate continues to be around 3.5%-4.0% at annual rate. More in general, wage growth continues to be more consistent with 3% rather than 2% core consumers prices readings going forward.
Note: the model expects a very strong (45bps) MoM AHE reading in March. See below for details.
(A PPT containing all US wage charts has been updated and posted here)
The facts
Average Hourly Earnings rose 14bps in February. In February, the sa MoM reading of AHE was a bit softer than the model expected (14bps vs 25bps expected), driven by a rebound in hours and a large drop in one sector (information), possibly due to seasonal adjustment issues (see here for a month with similar issues). The contribution of sectoral employment shifts is small, and the contribution of “residual calendarity” is null.
Note: if the reader is unfamiliar with the notion of “residual calendarity” in AHE space, (s)he can refer to this BLS page, and to our previous notes here, here, and here.
The AHE model
The “true” AHE pace continues to be around 3.5%-4% (ar). Figure 1 shows an update of our AHE monthly model. As a reminder, this model explains monthly AHE growth rates using recent past, a variable capturing “residual seasonality”, a variable capturing economic “slack”, and sectoral employment shares. In February (latest point on the chart), the fitted value of the model is a bit above the published AHE growth rate: 21bps vs 14bps.
We continue to take the blue line as the “true” signal, given it has provided good guidance so far. The overall message has not changed: the fitted values (blue line) are going roughly sideways, as argued in recent months. The average of the last 3 readings of the blue line is 32bps MoM sa or 3.8% at annual rate. Therefore, the “true” current pace of AHE is estimated in between 3.5% and 4.0%.
Figure 1. AHE MoM (sa) and UnderlyingInflation AHE model fitted values.
Note: the figure shows published MoM (sa) AHE growth rates (red line) and UnderlyingInflation AHE model fitted values (blue line). The figure excludes the first 6 months of Covid for scaling issues (although they are included in the model estimation).
Why sectoral shifts are crucial. We often get the following question: how important are sectoral employment shifts for AHE growth? Figure 2 clarifies why it is very important to control, somehow, for sectoral employment shifts. Figure 2 shows the published AHE YoY growth rate (the yellow line), and the share of employment in industries with AHE level above the aggregate mean. Figure 2 is not meant to say that industry shifts can explain everything. Rather, it is just a reminder not to take at face value the MoM (or YoY) of AHE when it pops up on your Bloomberg terminal.
Figure 2. YoY of AHE and Sectoral Employment Share.
What to expect in March
Very Strong AHE in March. According to the model, AHE MoM (sa) growth in March is expected at 0.45%. Please, remember that the model assumes no shift in employment shares across sectors and constant aggregate hours (we cannot forecast the weather..). The reason of the expected large MoM swing is once again “residual calendarity” (March has 10 weekend days vs 8 in February). Conditional on this forecast, the “true” AHE growth rate (blue line in Figure 1) would continue to be around 3.5%-4%.
Overview on nominal wage growth
Growing at 4%. Figure 3 shows the QoQ (saar) growth rates of 8 measures of nominal wage and total compensation growth (the gray lines) and their average (the blue line). The eight measures are: the AHE, the AWE (Average Weekly Earnings, the AHE numerator), the Atlanta Fed Wage Tracker (expressed as YoY), the Employment Cost Index (ECI), the ECI wages and salaries, the Compensation Per Hour (CPH), Non-farm business compensation (the CPH numerator), and the Unit Labor Cost (ULC). The dashed blue lines show the average pre and post Covid. The takeaway is that post-Covid wage growth has averaged around 5%, way above the pre-Covid average (3%+). In recent quarters, nominal compensation has averaged 4%, a value which remains more consistent with consumers prices running closer to 3% than to 2%.
Figure 3. Nominal wage growth across measures of wages and total compensation.
Note: the figure shows the QoQ (saar, %) of eight measures of nominal wage and total compensation growth. The eight measures are: the AHE, the AWE (Average Weekly Earnings, the AHE numerator), the Atlanta Fed Wage Tracker (expressed as YoY), the Employment Cost Index (ECI), the ECI wages and salaries, the Compensation Per Hour (CPH), Non-farm business compensation (the CPH numerator), and the Unit Labor Cost (ULC). Each measure is a gray line. The thick blue line is the average of the QoQ across measures. The dashed blue lines show the pre- and post-Covid mean of the thick blue line.