US: Pi* – When will it get to 2%? Some Bullet Points

A quick note to show the evolution of pi*. We got some emails asking the same: can you please show us the evolution of pi*? Will it be at 2% in March? Some important bullet points:

  • For the definition of pi* and why it is so important, please see here.
  • For the latest estimate of pi*, please see our pre-January 2024 FOMC meeting package (here), in particular page 16, 17, and 19 of the slides (here). Please, note what we wrote in the pre-FOMC meeting package: “Until the estimate of pi* will be lower and close to target, it will be hard to imagine a real dovish Fed”.
  • The evolution of pi*, as an average of the three methods to estimate it, since late 2021 is shown in Figure 1. Pi* is very persistent by nature. It went from a little below 2 percent in 2019-2020 (not shown) to a bit below 3% in late 2022. As mentioned, it is now at 2.5%, which means that it took about one year to decrease by a few tenths. For the record: in the same time span, the 3m/3m of core PCE went from 6.0% (Jan ’22) to 1.8% (Jan ’23, our estimate).
  • No single CPI print (or ECI print) can move pi* significantly. And there is no easy answer to the question “what moves pi*?”. The answer is “it’s complicated, and it’s a lot of things, including price inflation, wage inflation, expectations, etc..”.
  • Pi* can decrease (in fact, we expect it to do so) from now till the March round. It remains very difficult to say by how much, but history tells us that at most pi* changes by 2 tenths from one round to the next (and 1 tenth is more likely). For this reason, it is virtually impossible to have pi* at 2.0% in March, but it can be at 2.4% or 2.3%.
  • Because pi* is very persistent, it makes the Fed staff and the FOMC prone to be late. Indeed, by looking at Figure 1, the reader can see why the Fed waited so much before hiking, and what they really meant by “transitory” (“transitory” = pi* did not move much – but good luck explaining it to the markets!).

All told, cut or not in March? Yesterday Powell said the following: “we want to be sure that pi* falls further”. It remains unclear whether Powell and the FOMC wants to see the estimate of pi* at 2% (in which case, the probability of a March (but also of an April or June) cut is zero, or whether they can be satisfied with an estimate a bit above target. We suspect it is not clear in Powell’s mind at the moment. What we can do on our side is to keep providing you a real-time estimate of pi*.

Figure 1. Evolution of pi* in our estimates.

Note: the Figure shows the evolution of the three methods to estimate pi* (see Rudd (2020)): measures of trend inflation, measures of long-term inflation expectations, and the general equilibrium. In the figure, pi* is the average of the three methods.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.