US: October 2023 CPI Preview

Bad news. We see the October CPI report to bring a cold shower in core space. We expect the MoM (sa) of core CPI at 0.4% (37bps) and the MoM (sa) of headline CPI at 0.1% (14bps). We see the YoY of core CPI (PCE) at 3.9% (3.7%) in December. (For the record, we have judgmentally boosted our October MoM forecast by 4-5bps -both core and headline- because in the last 2 reports we got upward surprises, so we cannot have a third one).

We invite the reader to think about the following: 4%. Conditional on our forecast, the average of the MoM saar of the last 3 core CPIs (Aug-Sep-Oct) would be 4.0%. These numbers are way stronger that most forecasters expected only a few months ago. Not only, but the average since the beginning of the year (Jan-Oct) would be 4.1% and the expected YoY in December, as mentioned above, would also be 4%. The reality is probably not as bad as 4%, but we remain well above target. Translated: a good reminder that the US economy is probably still not out of the woods, that disinflation will take time, and that consequently we cannot expect monetary policy to turn dovish soon.

In our view, the baseline is that there will be no more hikes in 2023, although two 0.4% in core CPI (the November CPI will be on the first day of the December FOMC) can definitely put a hike on the table, especially because the estimated medium-term model (see below) can, once again, revise up its forecast.

Our forecast

We expect headline and core CPI to expand 14bps and 37bps in October, respectively (NSA levels 307.991 and 311.843, respectively). Figure 1 below shows the sectoral breakdown of our MoM (sa) forecast. We expect the MoM (sa) of core goods and core services to be 26bps and 44bps, respectively. As usual, we do not comment on the sectoral breakdown because we give much more importance to the ex-post distribution of price changes (latest one is here). Figure 2 shows our real-time MoM forecast errors: in the last 6 months, the std error and std deviation of our core CPI forecast (our main focus) are 4bps and 9bps, respectively.

Figure 1. MoM sa CPI forecast – details

Figure 2. Recent real-time Underlying Inflation MoM (sa) CPI forecast errors

Implications for the “main” model

Significant upward revisions. This month, we will include Q4 for the first time in-sample. Stopping the model estimation in Q3 produces a forecast for Q4 of 3.0% (QoQ saar). However, based on the expected MoM, we are now working with a nowcast of 3.7% for Q4. In other words, the inclusion of Q4 in-sample can trigger an upward revision of the model forecast. Specifically, conditional on our Q4 nowcast, the Q4/Q4 forecast of the model is: 3.0% in 2024, 2.8% in 2025, and 2.7% in 2026. Compared to the previous run, the forecast is revised up by 2-3 tenths in each year. Overall, the model continues to suggest that the widespread optimism about quickly reverting back to the 2% target is not justified.

Figure 3. Latest forecast of our “main” model for core PCE price inflation (YoY).

Conclusion

What optimism? Putting everything together, we are puzzled to see so many people (including Nobel laureates..) arguing that the war against inflation is over. Q4 was expected to show an acceleration of the monthly readings. Such acceleration can be even larger than anticipated, and the medium-term models can, once again, revise up their forecast. Is there any reason to be optimistic? We remain extremely cautious.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.