Last Hike Standing
July 2023 FOMC: hike… but why? The story for the July FOMC is pretty straightforward: the data and the models have started to cooperate and signal a potential turn of the FOMC. Withouth sounding triumphalist (there is no reason, given that returning to target is still a question mark), we see real progresses in the data. Most importantly, for the first time the “main” model forecast for 2023 is below the latest SEP and, in our estimates, the Fed staff can revise down (again) its medium-term forecast.
To sum up: if the FOMC will hike, it will do so “by inertia” and because it is already priced in. In reality, the data and the models support another skip. Conditional on our (and the Fed staff) forecast, we expect the FOMC to revise down its 2023 projection in the September SEP when it will become virtually impossible to hike again. At the July FOMC we expect Powell to leave all options on the table for September, but the suspect is that the data will force the Fed to stop hiking.
Main points:
- The incoming data have been weaker than expected by the Fed staff forecast inferred from the latest FOMC minutes. In our estimates, there should be room for a small downward revision to the near-term forecast of the Fed staff. Figure 1 shows the distribution of core (CPI) price changes updated to include the June report. The distribution remains very different than pre-Covid but there are visible signs of improvements: it is now centered around the Fed target and it is trying to disinflate the right tail. Making sure to reach target in the medium-term continues to require monetary policy to remain restrictive for quite some time (otherwise the suspect is that we could remain around 3% in the medium-term), but pushing the FF rate higher is now a question mark.
Figure 1. Core (CPI) prices change distributions.
- The Fed staff medium-term judgmental forecast (the Tealbook) can also be revised down marginally. The 2023 Fed staff forecast was already below the SEP forecast at the June meeting (3.7% vs 3.9%) and the gap can widen this round. Figure 2 shows the evolution of the 2023 (Q4/Q4) core PCE price inflation forecast across projections. The most relevant news is that for the first time, the “main” model forecast is below the latest SEP. We now expect the FOMC to revise down its 2023 forecast in the September SEP.
Figure 2. Comparison of the evolution of the 2023 (Q4/Q4) core PCE price inflation forecast.
- The Fed staff (2021) Taylor rule implies a terminal FF rate of 5.8% (reminder: these Taylor rules do NOT account for the effects of the credit tightening). The inertial Taylor rule implies a terminal rate of 6.0%, while FRB-US has a terminal rate of 5.7% (FF rate path in the post-CPI FRB-US run is here). Considering the effect of the credit tightening, the Fed can raise rates at this meeting “by inertia” but we assign a close-to-zero probability to a further hike in 2023.
Figure 3. Taylor rules.
As usual, we would be more than happy to schedule a meeting to discuss the details.