June 2023 FOMC: FRB-US Wins Everything!

Hawkish But They Know

No surprises, but now… what? The new SEP is almost identical to the latest run of FRB-US (our note here). Overall, there were no surprises from our point of view, just a touch more hawkish than expected. The interesting part, however, starts now. The Fed has signaled a higher terminal rate but it is really not clear what needs to happen for the FOMC to deliver two more hikes. Powell was not clear at all on this point, at least to our ears. Indeed, we suspect the Fed staff (and the FOMC) are well aware that the incoming data are a bit better than they look on the surface and that Q3 might bring some good news. As we mentioned in previous communications, we now see the higher terminal rate in the SEP as an “insurance” (a “just in case”). But at this point we are not sure the Fed will deliver two extra hikes.

(Chair Powell got several questions about inflation. We review only one of them because the others were not relevant. At the end of this note, a final word about today’s FOMC and press conference.)

The new SEP

The new SEP is almost identical to FRB-US. Table 1 shows the newly released economic projections. The median shows: a higher GDP growth, a lower unemployment rate, a higher path of core PCE price inflation, and a higher FF rate. The new forecasts are almost identical in 2023 to the latest run of FRB-US (our note here). The only surprise is that we expected a 5.3% terminal rate (vs 5.6% – which in any case squares well with the 5.9% of FRB-US minus a 50bps gap to account for the credit crunch). A very big victory lap for FRB-US.

Table1. Economic projections of the Federal Reserve.

Q&As

Question. Is the new SEP an even more “immaculate disinflation” than before?

Powell. “I think you go back to the to the three-part framework for core PCE inflation which is… we think of as good an indicator […] you start with goods we need to see continued healing and supply side conditions they have definitely improved a substantial amount. But if you talk to people in business, they will say it’s not back to where it was. So, that’s one thing and that should enable goods prices to continue to come down overtime. In terms of housing services inflation, that is another big piece and you are seeing that new rents are coming in at low levels and it’s really a matter of time as that goes through the pipeline. In fact, I think any forecast that people are making right now about inflation coming down this year will contain […] a good amount of disinflation from that source. […] That leaves you the big sector which is a little more than half of the core PCE inflation that is not-housing services and you know… we see only the earliest signs of disinflation there. It’s a sector, it’s a very broad and diverse sector. […] It is heavily labor intensive and I think many analysts would say that the key to getting inflation down there is to have a continuing loosening in labor market conditions… we have actually seen, you know, a number of indicators suggesting there’s been some losing in labor market conditions. We need to see that continue.”

Comment: Yes, Mr. Powell. We agree but we already knew all of it. The truth is that the FOMC (and the Fed staff) was forced to revise up again its core PCE price inflation forecast because it has ignored the model-based evidence (Figure 1 in this note). Finally, the model-based forecast and the SEP are not too far away any more. But the revisions in the SEP forecast of core inflation cannot be justified by the revisions of the other variables. Put it differently, last time an SEP forecast was internally consistent and/or estimated correctly the persistency of core inflation was probably before Covid.

A final word

Hard for the Fed to hike again, unless we get a big surprise. At the end of the day, the only relevant question is the following: why the Fed did not raise rates today? And what would it take to hike going forward? Powell tried to answer this question but we were unable to understand. The only real answer (in our view) is “a large upward surprise in core inflation”. In this environment everything can be (see Canada, UK, Australia, Norway) but if our forecast is correct, the MoM of core inflation (both CPI and PCE) in Q3 should be lower than in H1 and roughly consistent with the new SEP. Under that forecast, can the Fed hike again? We are really not sure at this point.

Contact

Want something more tailored?

We provide tailored consulting on ad-hoc projects.