The May 2023 FOMC Minutes contained a small surprise: the Fed staff revised up its 2023 judgmental core PCE price inflation forecast by 3 tenths (from 3.5% to 3.8%). We take this revision seriously because for the first time the Fed staff forecast is above the SEP. Given this evidence, we would not be surprised to see an upward revision of the SEP forecast at the upcoming June meeting.
The FOMC minutes
According to the minutes: “The staff’s core inflation forecast was revised up a little relative to the previous projection. Recent data for core PCE goods prices and the ECI measure of wage growth—the latter of which importantly influences the staff’s projection of core nonhousing services inflation—came in above expectations, and the staff judged that supply–demand imbalances in both goods markets and labor markets were easing a bit more slowly than anticipated. On a four-quarter change basis, total PCE price inflation was projected to be 3.1 percent this year, with core inflation at 3.8 percent.”
Evolution of the 2023 forecast
Room to revise up the SEP forecast at the June meeting. Figure 1 shows the evolution of the Q4/Q4 forecasts for core PCE price inflation. Our “main” model forecast is shown as a black line, the SEP is the red line, the Fed staff forecast (as inferred from the FOMC minutes) is the green line, and the NY Fed DSGE model is the yellow line. Overall, we are not surprised to see that the Fed staff was forced to revise up again its forecast, given that our “main” model has anticipated each revision in the last year and a half (Figure 1). However, we have been surprised by the Fed staff revision at the May meeting for three reasons. First, we expected the staff to revise up its forecast at the June meeting because in our estimates the incoming data (of core PCE as a whole) were close to what the staff expected. Second, the staff has admitted that the revision is driven mainly by higher-than-expected data on ECI. By doing so, the staff has acknowledged that at least some wage-price “spiral” is at play (translated: we need a significant moderation in wage inflation going forward). Third (and most importantly), the upward revision is large for a single non-SEP round and for the first time the green line in Figure 1 is above the red line. Considering that now our “main” model and the Fed staff are both above the SEP, we would not be suprised to see an upward revision of the SEP at the June meeting (say from 3.6% to 3.8%/3.9%).
Figure 1. Evolution of the 2023 (Q4/Q4) core PCE price inflation forecast (%)
Note: the chart shows the evolution of the Q4/Q4 core PCE price inflation forecast. The dates on the horizontal axis refer to the FOMC rounds. The “Fed staff” forecast is inferred from the FOMC minutes. The SEP line (as well as the “NY Fed DSGE”) is kept constant in non-SEP rounds. “Main model” refers to our main Phillips curve model based on Detmeister et al. (2014).
Conclusion and implications for the FF rate
Hike or not in June is a close call. No cut in 2023 should be a done deal. We are agnostic about a hike at the June meeting right now (gun pointed to our head we would say no hike). But the upward revision of the Fed staff at the May meeting is pretty significant and we now expect an upward revision of the SEP forecast in June. The data should start cooperating (at least to some extent) in the second half of the year. Having said so, our “main” model has correctly signaled the risks around the staff/FOMC forecast in the last year and a half. Until the model will point to downside risks, we think that the probability of a dovish Fed will remain close to zero. Right now, it is very hard to see how this can happen before the end of this year.